Skip to main content

Notice

Please note that most of the software linked on this forum is likely to be safe to use. If you are unsure, feel free to ask in the relevant topics, or send a private message to an administrator or moderator. To help curb the problems of false positives, or in the event that you do find actual malware, you can contribute through the article linked here.
Topic: looking for a aac. encoder comparison test... (Read 4309 times) previous topic - next topic
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

looking for a aac. encoder comparison test...

yup...


wondering if a comparison between those two.. are made..

also if there`s done a pure mp4. test
between those encoder`s aviable..

should be interesting reading.. me think.



looking for a aac. encoder comparison test...

Reply #1
Why not just try both and compare? Some say Nero AAC has worse pre-echo than Psytel AAC in some situations, i haven't tested this, but, i couldn't care less if i just read opinions of others. I trust my hearing, not just others'.
(I hope you're not looking for graphs or something, since graphs mean nothing)

 

looking for a aac. encoder comparison test...

Reply #2
I said it - tested with PsyTEL AAC 2.15 -archive & Ahead MP4 from Nero 5.5.100 -audiophile, on the castanet2.wav sample (find on the HA server). ABXed several time, on different moment of the day.
Precisely

looking for a aac. encoder comparison test...

Reply #3
Quote
Why not just try both and compare? Some say Nero AAC has worse pre-echo than Psytel AAC in some situations, i haven't tested this, but, i couldn't care less if i just read opinions of others. I trust my hearing, not just others'.
(I hope you're not looking for graphs or something, since graphs mean nothing)

yup...


now.. personaly.. i give a big ####.. about white papers.
(a set of good ears.. is all that is required.)
but in conjunction with bao. there was question about a comparison
between nero mp4.. and psytel aac..

the sample i encoded with qt.
was the worst aac sample.. i ever heard.


the award for best audio tweaker
in ** years in a row: Q-TIP