CD Drive Accuracy List

Topic: CD Drive Accuracy List (Read 22776 times) previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

CD Drive Accuracy List

2006-06-13 19:14:57

I have finally got around to running statistics on AccurateRip's database to generate a list of the most accurate drives, the results are quite suprising, the first table are only drives which have more than 20,000 tracks submitted:

Code: [Select]

Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-2510A   (58 users):   28792 Accurate Submissions     15503 Inaccurate      65%
Drive: BENQ     - DVD DD DW1640   (46 users):   13339 Accurate Submissions     8525 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-708A   (115 users):   34402 Accurate Submissions     22501 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4242N   (28 users):   15112 Accurate Submissions     10541 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-108   (66 users):   21282 Accurate Submissions     15410 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-52327S   (67 users):   15183 Accurate Submissions     11402 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-510A   (34 users):   11161 Accurate Submissions     8303 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4160B   (43 users):   12874 Accurate Submissions     9369 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: LITE-ON  - COMBO SOHC-5232K   (22 users):   11812 Accurate Submissions     9201 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3520AW   (37 users):   11825 Accurate Submissions     9494 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4241N   (44 users):   18479 Accurate Submissions     14624 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W5224A   (28 users):   11002 Accurate Submissions     9333 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-716A   (146 users):   51310 Accurate Submissions     42034 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4240N   (58 users):   15274 Accurate Submissions     14047 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PREMIUM   (115 users):   40857 Accurate Submissions     38053 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3540A   (80 users):   29654 Accurate Submissions     27827 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-832S   (49 users):   12706 Accurate Submissions     12346 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-712A   (99 users):   27140 Accurate Submissions     28058 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-2500A   (76 users):   17388 Accurate Submissions     17760 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8161B   (34 users):   13540 Accurate Submissions     14521 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3520A   (60 users):   17880 Accurate Submissions     18675 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-109   (48 users):   9165 Accurate Submissions     9687 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4163B   (114 users):   20956 Accurate Submissions     23574 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8483B   (18 users):   9090 Accurate Submissions     10138 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3500AG   (138 users):   41249 Accurate Submissions     46194 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-ROM PX-40TS   (39 users):   11526 Accurate Submissions     13446 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1612   (44 users):   9698 Accurate Submissions     11660 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVD SOHD-167T   (20 users):   8646 Accurate Submissions     10981 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: JLMS     - XJ-HD166S   (80 users):   15469 Accurate Submissions     20771 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-106D   (58 users):   9769 Accurate Submissions     13632 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4480B   (29 users):   17033 Accurate Submissions     23763 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-1300A   (59 users):   10723 Accurate Submissions     16037 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4120B   (42 users):   19742 Accurate Submissions     30465 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: ASUS     - DVD-E616P   (11 users):   4034 Accurate Submissions     20045 Inaccurate      16%

All drives in % order:

Code: [Select]

Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SM-348B   (11 users):   10478 Accurate Submissions     3742 Inaccurate      73%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-115   (10 users):   1241 Accurate Submissions     460 Inaccurate      72%
Drive: TDK      - DVDRW0404N   (11 users):   3761 Accurate Submissions     1397 Inaccurate      72%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-120S   (13 users):   3072 Accurate Submissions     1164 Inaccurate      72%
Drive: LITE-ON  - COMBO LTC-48161H   (29 users):   8272 Accurate Submissions     3706 Inaccurate      69%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX216E   (10 users):   1225 Accurate Submissions     547 Inaccurate      69%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R2102   (27 users):   5602 Accurate Submissions     2476 Inaccurate      69%
Drive: JLMS     - DVD-ROM XJ-HD166   (10 users):   1471 Accurate Submissions     678 Inaccurate      68%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-2510A   (58 users):   28792 Accurate Submissions     15503 Inaccurate      65%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1912   (11 users):   509 Accurate Submissions     265 Inaccurate      65%
Drive: ATAPI    - DVD DD 2X16X4X16   (10 users):   755 Accurate Submissions     404 Inaccurate      65%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DW-D22A   (10 users):   3500 Accurate Submissions     2049 Inaccurate      63%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-ROM PX-32TS   (10 users):   1817 Accurate Submissions     1057 Inaccurate      63%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-710A   (29 users):   7963 Accurate Submissions     4490 Inaccurate      63%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-4550A   (22 users):   7442 Accurate Submissions     4416 Inaccurate      62%
Drive: LITEON   - DVD-ROM LTD163   (34 users):   11953 Accurate Submissions     7238 Inaccurate      62%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-R-RW SW-248F   (21 users):   2374 Accurate Submissions     1397 Inaccurate      62%
Drive: BENQ     - DVD DD DW1640   (46 users):   13339 Accurate Submissions     8525 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-RW GWA-4082N   (14 users):   3116 Accurate Submissions     1943 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - DVD-ROM SD-616F   (16 users):   1771 Accurate Submissions     1089 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-120   (12 users):   9289 Accurate Submissions     5796 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-116   (19 users):   1206 Accurate Submissions     791 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-708A   (115 users):   34402 Accurate Submissions     22501 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-500A   (30 users):   9053 Accurate Submissions     5851 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX220E1   (10 users):   2433 Accurate Submissions     1608 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-52246S   (45 users):   7002 Accurate Submissions     4779 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA750 DVD-CDRW   (13 users):   8441 Accurate Submissions     5683 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-110D   (18 users):   2514 Accurate Submissions     1680 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-720A   (10 users):   2958 Accurate Submissions     2029 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SN-324F   (16 users):   3587 Accurate Submissions     2478 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: _NEC     - NR-7800A   (11 users):   3046 Accurate Submissions     2099 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: TEAC     - DW-224E   (15 users):   8819 Accurate Submissions     5951 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4242N   (28 users):   15112 Accurate Submissions     10541 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-108   (66 users):   21282 Accurate Submissions     15410 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW LDW-811S   (20 users):   4204 Accurate Submissions     3031 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8481B   (19 users):   3312 Accurate Submissions     2316 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-40125S   (25 users):   3985 Accurate Submissions     2921 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-52327S   (67 users):   15183 Accurate Submissions     11402 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-510A   (34 users):   11161 Accurate Submissions     8303 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4160B   (43 users):   12874 Accurate Submissions     9369 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: QSI      - CDRW-DVD SBW242C   (10 users):   2342 Accurate Submissions     1765 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CD-DVDW TS-H552B   (12 users):   915 Accurate Submissions     668 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: MATSHITA - DVD-RAM UJ-812   (10 users):   3789 Accurate Submissions     2871 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW LDW-411S   (15 users):   4374 Accurate Submissions     3347 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8160B   (14 users):   1822 Accurate Submissions     1427 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: LITE-ON  - COMBO SOHC-5232K   (22 users):   11812 Accurate Submissions     9201 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CD-DVDW TS-H552U   (17 users):   6023 Accurate Submissions     4854 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - DVD-ROM SD-616E   (23 users):   5030 Accurate Submissions     3969 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3520AW   (37 users):   11825 Accurate Submissions     9494 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4241N   (44 users):   18479 Accurate Submissions     14624 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W5224A   (28 users):   11002 Accurate Submissions     9333 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: SONY     - CDRW-DVD CRX830E   (15 users):   4308 Accurate Submissions     3666 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-716A   (146 users):   51310 Accurate Submissions     42034 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: SONY     - DVD-ROM DDU1615   (18 users):   7497 Accurate Submissions     6267 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: JLMS     - XJ-HD165H   (13 users):   9107 Accurate Submissions     7840 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX320E   (10 users):   4816 Accurate Submissions     4125 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - DVD-ROM SD-616T   (21 users):   8846 Accurate Submissions     7762 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: SONY     - DVD-ROM DDU1621   (11 users):   1756 Accurate Submissions     1525 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1502   (10 users):   3062 Accurate Submissions     2685 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - CDRW-DVD SDR2102   (11 users):   3042 Accurate Submissions     2659 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R2512   (23 users):   2954 Accurate Submissions     2591 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-C2502   (16 users):   2977 Accurate Submissions     2674 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SN-324B   (17 users):   2927 Accurate Submissions     2674 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: HP       - DVD Writer 640c   (12 users):   2174 Accurate Submissions     1966 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVD SOHD-16P9S   (10 users):   2667 Accurate Submissions     2395 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1693S   (31 users):   4466 Accurate Submissions     4098 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4240N   (58 users):   15274 Accurate Submissions     14047 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+-RW ND-3530A   (10 users):   2291 Accurate Submissions     2062 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-530A   (17 users):   2445 Accurate Submissions     2290 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: SONY     - DVD-ROM DDU1612   (16 users):   4219 Accurate Submissions     3945 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: SONY     - DVD+-RW DW-D56A   (16 users):   4623 Accurate Submissions     4285 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-110   (10 users):   1228 Accurate Submissions     1168 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: YAMAHA   - CRW-F1E   (34 users):   6294 Accurate Submissions     5878 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R6112   (15 users):   3769 Accurate Submissions     3495 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PREMIUM   (115 users):   40857 Accurate Submissions     38053 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3540A   (80 users):   29654 Accurate Submissions     27827 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+RW ND-5100A   (11 users):   3891 Accurate Submissions     3666 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CDW-DVD TS-H492A   (15 users):   9161 Accurate Submissions     8723 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: CDWRITER - IDE5224   (11 users):   1489 Accurate Submissions     1483 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8240B   (11 users):   1665 Accurate Submissions     1657 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-832S   (49 users):   12706 Accurate Submissions     12346 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX230E   (10 users):   1289 Accurate Submissions     1283 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: Lite-On  - LTN486S 48x Max   (12 users):   2512 Accurate Submissions     2497 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA755zDVD-CDRW   (12 users):   2525 Accurate Submissions     2472 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-712A   (99 users):   27140 Accurate Submissions     28058 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD+RW GCA-4040N   (23 users):   6550 Accurate Submissions     6759 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8320B   (13 users):   1869 Accurate Submissions     1934 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-2500A   (76 users):   17388 Accurate Submissions     17760 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-104   (14 users):   3363 Accurate Submissions     3455 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CD-DVDW SH-W162C   (10 users):   1171 Accurate Submissions     1204 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: TDK      - CDRW4800B   (12 users):   4012 Accurate Submissions     4308 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8161B   (34 users):   13540 Accurate Submissions     14521 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: MATSHITA - DVD-RAM UJ-820S   (21 users):   7771 Accurate Submissions     8192 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3520A   (60 users):   17880 Accurate Submissions     18675 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-106   (28 users):   4368 Accurate Submissions     4573 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-107D   (40 users):   6928 Accurate Submissions     7391 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-109   (48 users):   9165 Accurate Submissions     9687 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4163B   (114 users):   20956 Accurate Submissions     23574 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: LG       - CD-RW CED-8080B   (11 users):   1576 Accurate Submissions     1709 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1633S   (44 users):   8736 Accurate Submissions     9696 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8483B   (18 users):   9090 Accurate Submissions     10138 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8162B   (32 users):   4329 Accurate Submissions     4818 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4243N   (24 users):   7341 Accurate Submissions     8168 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4481B   (15 users):   7034 Accurate Submissions     7851 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3500AG   (138 users):   41249 Accurate Submissions     46194 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W4012A   (43 users):   7191 Accurate Submissions     8079 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - ODD-DVD SD-M1802   (13 users):   1179 Accurate Submissions     1312 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4081B   (24 users):   5573 Accurate Submissions     6421 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-ROM PX-40TS   (39 users):   11526 Accurate Submissions     13446 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CDRW-DVD TSL462C   (13 users):   2200 Accurate Submissions     2484 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - ODD-DVD SD-R6372   (14 users):   3181 Accurate Submissions     3667 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: BENQ     - DVD DD DW1620   (43 users):   8006 Accurate Submissions     9636 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1612   (44 users):   9698 Accurate Submissions     11660 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W2410A   (40 users):   5774 Accurate Submissions     6912 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4040B   (40 users):   1998 Accurate Submissions     2386 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-812S   (15 users):   1769 Accurate Submissions     2122 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3550A   (29 users):   6450 Accurate Submissions     7594 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R9012   (19 users):   5701 Accurate Submissions     6779 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-740A   (28 users):   5126 Accurate Submissions     6385 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: DVDRW    - IDE 16X   (18 users):   2386 Accurate Submissions     2931 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: QSI      - CDRW-DVD SBW-241   (10 users):   2418 Accurate Submissions     2993 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SM-352F   (10 users):   5453 Accurate Submissions     6927 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVD SOHD-167T   (20 users):   8646 Accurate Submissions     10981 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: TSSTcorp - DVD-ROM TS-H352A   (11 users):   794 Accurate Submissions     1002 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W1610A   (17 users):   407 Accurate Submissions     512 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R2312   (20 users):   3903 Accurate Submissions     5022 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX100E   (10 users):   461 Accurate Submissions     591 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8400B   (32 users):   5202 Accurate Submissions     6638 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-105   (23 users):   3536 Accurate Submissions     4522 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+RW ND-6100A   (13 users):   4494 Accurate Submissions     5955 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-700A   (11 users):   2775 Accurate Submissions     3781 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: JLMS     - XJ-HD166S   (80 users):   15469 Accurate Submissions     20771 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: ASUS     - CRW-5224A   (12 users):   1832 Accurate Submissions     2503 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-48246S   (18 users):   1435 Accurate Submissions     1930 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8082N   (14 users):   1437 Accurate Submissions     1942 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA755 DVD-CDRW   (10 users):   443 Accurate Submissions     607 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVD-ROM PX-130A   (14 users):   1803 Accurate Submissions     2539 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8520B   (23 users):   3978 Accurate Submissions     5576 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-106D   (58 users):   9769 Accurate Submissions     13632 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: QSI      - CDRW-DVD SBW-242   (32 users):   3971 Accurate Submissions     5549 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4480B   (29 users):   17033 Accurate Submissions     23763 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4167B   (36 users):   5530 Accurate Submissions     8023 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CDRW-DVD GCC4244   (12 users):   1992 Accurate Submissions     2952 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-1300A   (59 users):   10723 Accurate Submissions     16037 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W1210A   (29 users):   5716 Accurate Submissions     8333 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+-RW ND-6650A   (29 users):   5994 Accurate Submissions     8803 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-C2612   (12 users):   2457 Accurate Submissions     3733 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW LDW-451S   (10 users):   1092 Accurate Submissions     1646 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8526B   (18 users):   2298 Accurate Submissions     3593 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4521B   (19 users):   3847 Accurate Submissions     5780 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4120B   (42 users):   19742 Accurate Submissions     30465 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA745 DVD-CDRW   (18 users):   7161 Accurate Submissions     11062 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: TEAC     - CD-224E   (12 users):   1742 Accurate Submissions     2707 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-R-RW SW-252S   (15 users):   3370 Accurate Submissions     5297 Inaccurate      38%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+-RW ND-6500A   (42 users):   5516 Accurate Submissions     8849 Inaccurate      38%
Drive: PHILIPS  - CDRW-DVD CDD5263   (11 users):   1836 Accurate Submissions     2999 Inaccurate      37%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1712   (49 users):   5663 Accurate Submissions     9496 Inaccurate      37%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1653S   (18 users):   2116 Accurate Submissions     3604 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-48125W   (20 users):   1149 Accurate Submissions     1998 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: IDE      - DVD-ROM 16X   (15 users):   2434 Accurate Submissions     4166 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W4824A   (50 users):   5534 Accurate Submissions     9612 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4082B   (22 users):   1130 Accurate Submissions     2014 Inaccurate      35%
Drive: TEAC     - CD-W540E   (10 users):   428 Accurate Submissions     823 Inaccurate      34%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8525B   (14 users):   1192 Accurate Submissions     2297 Inaccurate      34%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1673S   (22 users):   5315 Accurate Submissions     10073 Inaccurate      34%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8163B   (38 users):   4816 Accurate Submissions     9410 Inaccurate      33%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SM-352B   (21 users):   3608 Accurate Submissions     7077 Inaccurate      33%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SHW-1635S   (11 users):   2178 Accurate Submissions     4441 Inaccurate      32%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8523B   (12 users):   475 Accurate Submissions     973 Inaccurate      32%
Drive: ASUS     - DVD-ROM E616   (15 users):   802 Accurate Submissions     1645 Inaccurate      32%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+RW ND-1100A   (17 users):   4495 Accurate Submissions     9901 Inaccurate      31%
Drive: DVDRW    - IDE1008   (22 users):   1165 Accurate Submissions     2549 Inaccurate      31%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-ROM SC-148C   (11 users):   334 Accurate Submissions     764 Inaccurate      30%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-24102B   (24 users):   2886 Accurate Submissions     6456 Inaccurate      30%
Drive: LG       - DVD-ROM DRD8160B   (22 users):   655 Accurate Submissions     1743 Inaccurate      27%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-32123S   (13 users):   1299 Accurate Submissions     3355 Inaccurate      27%
Drive: LITE-ON  - CD-RW SOHR-5238S   (16 users):   4670 Accurate Submissions     14043 Inaccurate      24%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-R-RW SW-252B   (10 users):   413 Accurate Submissions     1608 Inaccurate      20%
Drive: ASUS     - DVD-E616P   (11 users):   4034 Accurate Submissions     20045 Inaccurate      16%

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #1 – 2006-06-13 19:57:38

Spoon,

Despite my being critical about this earlier, I'd like to thank you for taking the time to do this.

Thanks.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #2 – 2006-06-13 20:16:20

Alphabetic order (didn't come out right in first post, perhaps post size):

Code: [Select]

Drive: ASUS     - CRW-5224A   (12 users):   1832 Accurate Submissions     2503 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: ASUS     - DVD-E616P   (11 users):   4034 Accurate Submissions     20045 Inaccurate      16%
Drive: ASUS     - DVD-ROM E616   (15 users):   802 Accurate Submissions     1645 Inaccurate      32%
Drive: ATAPI    - DVD DD 2X16X4X16   (10 users):   755 Accurate Submissions     404 Inaccurate      65%
Drive: BENQ     - DVD DD DW1620   (43 users):   8006 Accurate Submissions     9636 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: BENQ     - DVD DD DW1640   (46 users):   13339 Accurate Submissions     8525 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: CDWRITER - IDE5224   (11 users):   1489 Accurate Submissions     1483 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: DVDRW    - IDE 16X   (18 users):   2386 Accurate Submissions     2931 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: DVDRW    - IDE1008   (22 users):   1165 Accurate Submissions     2549 Inaccurate      31%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8160B   (14 users):   1822 Accurate Submissions     1427 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8240B   (11 users):   1665 Accurate Submissions     1657 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8320B   (13 users):   1869 Accurate Submissions     1934 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8400B   (32 users):   5202 Accurate Submissions     6638 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8481B   (19 users):   3312 Accurate Submissions     2316 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8483B   (18 users):   9090 Accurate Submissions     10138 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8520B   (23 users):   3978 Accurate Submissions     5576 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8523B   (12 users):   475 Accurate Submissions     973 Inaccurate      32%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8525B   (14 users):   1192 Accurate Submissions     2297 Inaccurate      34%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CD-RW GCE-8526B   (18 users):   2298 Accurate Submissions     3593 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - CDRW-DVD GCC4244   (12 users):   1992 Accurate Submissions     2952 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD+RW GCA-4040N   (23 users):   6550 Accurate Submissions     6759 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8082N   (14 users):   1437 Accurate Submissions     1942 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8161B   (34 users):   13540 Accurate Submissions     14521 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8162B   (32 users):   4329 Accurate Submissions     4818 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-ROM GDR8163B   (38 users):   4816 Accurate Submissions     9410 Inaccurate      33%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVD-RW GWA-4082N   (14 users):   3116 Accurate Submissions     1943 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4040B   (40 users):   1998 Accurate Submissions     2386 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4081B   (24 users):   5573 Accurate Submissions     6421 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4082B   (22 users):   1130 Accurate Submissions     2014 Inaccurate      35%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4120B   (42 users):   19742 Accurate Submissions     30465 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4160B   (43 users):   12874 Accurate Submissions     9369 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4163B   (114 users):   20956 Accurate Submissions     23574 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - DVDRAM GSA-4167B   (36 users):   5530 Accurate Submissions     8023 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4240N   (58 users):   15274 Accurate Submissions     14047 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4241N   (44 users):   18479 Accurate Submissions     14624 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4242N   (28 users):   15112 Accurate Submissions     10541 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4243N   (24 users):   7341 Accurate Submissions     8168 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4480B   (29 users):   17033 Accurate Submissions     23763 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4481B   (15 users):   7034 Accurate Submissions     7851 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: HL-DT-ST - RW-DVD GCC-4521B   (19 users):   3847 Accurate Submissions     5780 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: HP       - DVD Writer 640c   (12 users):   2174 Accurate Submissions     1966 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: IDE      - DVD-ROM 16X   (15 users):   2434 Accurate Submissions     4166 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: JLMS     - DVD-ROM XJ-HD166   (10 users):   1471 Accurate Submissions     678 Inaccurate      68%
Drive: JLMS     - XJ-HD165H   (13 users):   9107 Accurate Submissions     7840 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: JLMS     - XJ-HD166S   (80 users):   15469 Accurate Submissions     20771 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: LG       - CD-RW CED-8080B   (11 users):   1576 Accurate Submissions     1709 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: LG       - DVD-ROM DRD8160B   (22 users):   655 Accurate Submissions     1743 Inaccurate      27%
Drive: LITE-ON  - CD-RW SOHR-5238S   (16 users):   4670 Accurate Submissions     14043 Inaccurate      24%
Drive: LITE-ON  - COMBO LTC-48161H   (29 users):   8272 Accurate Submissions     3706 Inaccurate      69%
Drive: LITE-ON  - COMBO SOHC-5232K   (22 users):   11812 Accurate Submissions     9201 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVD SOHD-167T   (20 users):   8646 Accurate Submissions     10981 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVD SOHD-16P9S   (10 users):   2667 Accurate Submissions     2395 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW LDW-411S   (15 users):   4374 Accurate Submissions     3347 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW LDW-451S   (10 users):   1092 Accurate Submissions     1646 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW LDW-811S   (20 users):   4204 Accurate Submissions     3031 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SHW-1635S   (11 users):   2178 Accurate Submissions     4441 Inaccurate      32%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1633S   (44 users):   8736 Accurate Submissions     9696 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1653S   (18 users):   2116 Accurate Submissions     3604 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1673S   (22 users):   5315 Accurate Submissions     10073 Inaccurate      34%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-1693S   (31 users):   4466 Accurate Submissions     4098 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-812S   (15 users):   1769 Accurate Submissions     2122 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: LITE-ON  - DVDRW SOHW-832S   (49 users):   12706 Accurate Submissions     12346 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: Lite-On  - LTN486S 48x Max   (12 users):   2512 Accurate Submissions     2497 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-24102B   (24 users):   2886 Accurate Submissions     6456 Inaccurate      30%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-32123S   (13 users):   1299 Accurate Submissions     3355 Inaccurate      27%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-40125S   (25 users):   3985 Accurate Submissions     2921 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-48125W   (20 users):   1149 Accurate Submissions     1998 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-48246S   (18 users):   1435 Accurate Submissions     1930 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-52246S   (45 users):   7002 Accurate Submissions     4779 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: LITE-ON  - LTR-52327S   (67 users):   15183 Accurate Submissions     11402 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: LITEON   - DVD-ROM LTD163   (34 users):   11953 Accurate Submissions     7238 Inaccurate      62%
Drive: MATSHITA - DVD-RAM UJ-812   (10 users):   3789 Accurate Submissions     2871 Inaccurate      56%
Drive: MATSHITA - DVD-RAM UJ-820S   (21 users):   7771 Accurate Submissions     8192 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA745 DVD-CDRW   (18 users):   7161 Accurate Submissions     11062 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA750 DVD-CDRW   (13 users):   8441 Accurate Submissions     5683 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA755 DVD-CDRW   (10 users):   443 Accurate Submissions     607 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: MATSHITA - UJDA755zDVD-CDRW   (12 users):   2525 Accurate Submissions     2472 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: PHILIPS  - CDRW-DVD CDD5263   (11 users):   1836 Accurate Submissions     2999 Inaccurate      37%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-106   (28 users):   4368 Accurate Submissions     4573 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-115   (10 users):   1241 Accurate Submissions     460 Inaccurate      72%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-116   (19 users):   1206 Accurate Submissions     791 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-120   (12 users):   9289 Accurate Submissions     5796 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-ROM DVD-120S   (13 users):   3072 Accurate Submissions     1164 Inaccurate      72%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-104   (14 users):   3363 Accurate Submissions     3455 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-105   (23 users):   3536 Accurate Submissions     4522 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-106D   (58 users):   9769 Accurate Submissions     13632 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-107D   (40 users):   6928 Accurate Submissions     7391 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-108   (66 users):   21282 Accurate Submissions     15410 Inaccurate      58%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-109   (48 users):   9165 Accurate Submissions     9687 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-110   (10 users):   1228 Accurate Submissions     1168 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: PIONEER  - DVD-RW  DVR-110D   (18 users):   2514 Accurate Submissions     1680 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PREMIUM   (115 users):   40857 Accurate Submissions     38053 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W1210A   (29 users):   5716 Accurate Submissions     8333 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W1610A   (17 users):   407 Accurate Submissions     512 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W2410A   (40 users):   5774 Accurate Submissions     6912 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W4012A   (43 users):   7191 Accurate Submissions     8079 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W4824A   (50 users):   5534 Accurate Submissions     9612 Inaccurate      36%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-R   PX-W5224A   (28 users):   11002 Accurate Submissions     9333 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-ROM PX-32TS   (10 users):   1817 Accurate Submissions     1057 Inaccurate      63%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - CD-ROM PX-40TS   (39 users):   11526 Accurate Submissions     13446 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVD-ROM PX-130A   (14 users):   1803 Accurate Submissions     2539 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-708A   (115 users):   34402 Accurate Submissions     22501 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-712A   (99 users):   27140 Accurate Submissions     28058 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-716A   (146 users):   51310 Accurate Submissions     42034 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: PLEXTOR  - DVDR   PX-740A   (28 users):   5126 Accurate Submissions     6385 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: QSI      - CDRW-DVD SBW-241   (10 users):   2418 Accurate Submissions     2993 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: QSI      - CDRW-DVD SBW-242   (32 users):   3971 Accurate Submissions     5549 Inaccurate      41%
Drive: QSI      - CDRW-DVD SBW242C   (10 users):   2342 Accurate Submissions     1765 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-R-RW SW-248F   (21 users):   2374 Accurate Submissions     1397 Inaccurate      62%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-R-RW SW-252B   (10 users):   413 Accurate Submissions     1608 Inaccurate      20%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-R-RW SW-252S   (15 users):   3370 Accurate Submissions     5297 Inaccurate      38%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CD-ROM SC-148C   (11 users):   334 Accurate Submissions     764 Inaccurate      30%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SM-348B   (11 users):   10478 Accurate Submissions     3742 Inaccurate      73%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SM-352B   (21 users):   3608 Accurate Submissions     7077 Inaccurate      33%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SM-352F   (10 users):   5453 Accurate Submissions     6927 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SN-324B   (17 users):   2927 Accurate Submissions     2674 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - CDRW-DVD SN-324F   (16 users):   3587 Accurate Submissions     2478 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - DVD-ROM SD-616E   (23 users):   5030 Accurate Submissions     3969 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - DVD-ROM SD-616F   (16 users):   1771 Accurate Submissions     1089 Inaccurate      61%
Drive: SAMSUNG  - DVD-ROM SD-616T   (21 users):   8846 Accurate Submissions     7762 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX100E   (10 users):   461 Accurate Submissions     591 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX216E   (10 users):   1225 Accurate Submissions     547 Inaccurate      69%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX220E1   (10 users):   2433 Accurate Submissions     1608 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX230E   (10 users):   1289 Accurate Submissions     1283 Inaccurate      50%
Drive: SONY     - CD-RW  CRX320E   (10 users):   4816 Accurate Submissions     4125 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: SONY     - CDRW-DVD CRX830E   (15 users):   4308 Accurate Submissions     3666 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-500A   (30 users):   9053 Accurate Submissions     5851 Inaccurate      60%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-510A   (34 users):   11161 Accurate Submissions     8303 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-530A   (17 users):   2445 Accurate Submissions     2290 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-700A   (11 users):   2775 Accurate Submissions     3781 Inaccurate      42%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-710A   (29 users):   7963 Accurate Submissions     4490 Inaccurate      63%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DRU-720A   (10 users):   2958 Accurate Submissions     2029 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: SONY     - DVD RW DW-D22A   (10 users):   3500 Accurate Submissions     2049 Inaccurate      63%
Drive: SONY     - DVD+-RW DW-D56A   (16 users):   4623 Accurate Submissions     4285 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: SONY     - DVD-ROM DDU1612   (16 users):   4219 Accurate Submissions     3945 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: SONY     - DVD-ROM DDU1615   (18 users):   7497 Accurate Submissions     6267 Inaccurate      54%
Drive: SONY     - DVD-ROM DDU1621   (11 users):   1756 Accurate Submissions     1525 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TDK      - CDRW4800B   (12 users):   4012 Accurate Submissions     4308 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: TDK      - DVDRW0404N   (11 users):   3761 Accurate Submissions     1397 Inaccurate      72%
Drive: TEAC     - CD-224E   (12 users):   1742 Accurate Submissions     2707 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: TEAC     - CD-W540E   (10 users):   428 Accurate Submissions     823 Inaccurate      34%
Drive: TEAC     - DW-224E   (15 users):   8819 Accurate Submissions     5951 Inaccurate      59%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - CDRW-DVD SDR2102   (11 users):   3042 Accurate Submissions     2659 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-C2502   (16 users):   2977 Accurate Submissions     2674 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-C2612   (12 users):   2457 Accurate Submissions     3733 Inaccurate      39%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1502   (10 users):   3062 Accurate Submissions     2685 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1612   (44 users):   9698 Accurate Submissions     11660 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1712   (49 users):   5663 Accurate Submissions     9496 Inaccurate      37%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-M1912   (11 users):   509 Accurate Submissions     265 Inaccurate      65%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R2102   (27 users):   5602 Accurate Submissions     2476 Inaccurate      69%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R2312   (20 users):   3903 Accurate Submissions     5022 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R2512   (23 users):   2954 Accurate Submissions     2591 Inaccurate      53%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R6112   (15 users):   3769 Accurate Submissions     3495 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - DVD-ROM SD-R9012   (19 users):   5701 Accurate Submissions     6779 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - ODD-DVD SD-M1802   (13 users):   1179 Accurate Submissions     1312 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: TOSHIBA  - ODD-DVD SD-R6372   (14 users):   3181 Accurate Submissions     3667 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CD-DVDW SH-W162C   (10 users):   1171 Accurate Submissions     1204 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CD-DVDW TS-H552B   (12 users):   915 Accurate Submissions     668 Inaccurate      57%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CD-DVDW TS-H552U   (17 users):   6023 Accurate Submissions     4854 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CDRW-DVD TSL462C   (13 users):   2200 Accurate Submissions     2484 Inaccurate      46%
Drive: TSSTcorp - CDW-DVD TS-H492A   (15 users):   9161 Accurate Submissions     8723 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: TSSTcorp - DVD-ROM TS-H352A   (11 users):   794 Accurate Submissions     1002 Inaccurate      44%
Drive: YAMAHA   - CRW-F1E   (34 users):   6294 Accurate Submissions     5878 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+-RW ND-3530A   (10 users):   2291 Accurate Submissions     2062 Inaccurate      52%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+-RW ND-6500A   (42 users):   5516 Accurate Submissions     8849 Inaccurate      38%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+-RW ND-6650A   (29 users):   5994 Accurate Submissions     8803 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+RW ND-1100A   (17 users):   4495 Accurate Submissions     9901 Inaccurate      31%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+RW ND-5100A   (11 users):   3891 Accurate Submissions     3666 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD+RW ND-6100A   (13 users):   4494 Accurate Submissions     5955 Inaccurate      43%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-1300A   (59 users):   10723 Accurate Submissions     16037 Inaccurate      40%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-2500A   (76 users):   17388 Accurate Submissions     17760 Inaccurate      49%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-2510A   (58 users):   28792 Accurate Submissions     15503 Inaccurate      65%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3500AG   (138 users):   41249 Accurate Submissions     46194 Inaccurate      47%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3520A   (60 users):   17880 Accurate Submissions     18675 Inaccurate      48%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3520AW   (37 users):   11825 Accurate Submissions     9494 Inaccurate      55%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3540A   (80 users):   29654 Accurate Submissions     27827 Inaccurate      51%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-3550A   (29 users):   6450 Accurate Submissions     7594 Inaccurate      45%
Drive: _NEC     - DVD_RW ND-4550A   (22 users):   7442 Accurate Submissions     4416 Inaccurate      62%
Drive: _NEC     - NR-7800A   (11 users):   3046 Accurate Submissions     2099 Inaccurate      59%

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #3 – 2006-06-13 20:33:02

The highest drive goes to 73%, that does not mean 1/4 of all tracks ripped on the best drive will be bad, rather that this percentage of tracks is likely not to be in accuraterips database (any track not in the database has to be reported as inaccurate, as that is how accuraterip works, it is a confidence system).

Lets look at certain drives, clearly the ASUS - DVD-E616P is an awful drive.

Plextors, they performed quite average overall, with the PX-708A flying the flag, and PX-W4824A being the worst Plextor.

Sony do well overall with almost all their drives over 50%.

The later Pioneers seem very good (although there are not enough track submissions to be sure).

Pio: You mentioned (on another thread) there are certain flawed CD drives - can you pick them out of this list?

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #4 – 2006-06-13 20:51:32

Fascinating. Thanks for doing it.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #5 – 2006-06-13 20:52:04

The problem is that you cannot determine how many of these submitted tracks were ripped off e.g. flawed CD-R's or are due to different CD pressings ... and I am not sure whether these circumstances are evenly distributed among all drives.

The Plextor 740 and the BenQ 1640 are basically the same drives and show a totally different data set in your statistics ...

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #6 – 2006-06-13 21:03:35

PLEXTOR - DVDR PX-740A (28 users): 5126 Accurate Submissions 6385 Inaccurate 44%
BENQ - DVD DD DW1640 (46 users): 13339 Accurate Submissions 8525 Inaccurate 61%

Same drive, firmware the same?

There will be a % error, the difference between these two drives is 17%, the 740 does not appear in the top table because it does not have enough tracks submitted.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #7 – 2006-06-13 21:05:21

Good to see NEC ND-3540A up there since I've had my eyes on the ND-3550As on Newegg.com. I'm assuming like with other NECs the tiny step in numbers means they have the same guts.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #8 – 2006-06-13 21:08:44

Thanks for the statistics, Spoon.
I also wonder if they are meaningful or just random. I've not got the energy to evaluate this now

I don't remember what the faulty drives are. Looking for Toshiba and Samsung in the EAC forum should bring them on. The Toshiba returned a single read error in every rip, always at the same place, and the Samsung muted the end of every track.

The faulty Teac is the CD-540E. I don't know if this is the same as the CD-W540E. Anyway, according to Feurio's database, it is only inaccurate with firmware 3.0, not with firmware 1.x. But sometimes, it manages to get a good rip. In fact it is inaccurate at high speed, and the 3.0 firmware is the one allowing high speed audio extraction.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #9 – 2006-06-20 16:59:22

Interesting as the numbers may seem, at this stage in the database development publishing them is premature, IMO. They might give you an idea of the drives's relative accuracy if the percentage of Not In Database discs were exactly the same among all the users. As even such an assumption would be unrealistic, the current results must be considered not only meaningless, but outright misleading.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #10 – 2006-06-20 17:08:04

I'm surprised with the results for the BenQ 1640.

I have one, but according to EAC it says it caches data but doesn't support C2 error correction.

Can a drive be that accurate while not supporting C2?

In contrast, my other drive, and LG4167 in EAC says that it doesn't cache data, and does support C2.

However, apparently the LG4167 does in fact cache data, and is reported as doing so in some other CD applications.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #11 – 2006-06-20 17:25:15

Thanks spoon for posting. I echo the lack statistical value of the results though. Regardless of being a statistically accurate description of the results, they are still interesting.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #12 – 2006-06-20 20:53:18

Whilst in an ideal world each drive would have more submissions (one of the Plextors has close to 100,000 tracks) I think the results shouldnt e disregarded quickly (think the recent ct test, how many times did they rip 100? those statistics above have close to 1 million track rips).

>Can a drive be that accurate while not supporting C2?

...or badly, yes

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #13 – 2006-06-21 04:11:30

Quote from: JeanLuc on 2006-06-13 20:52:04

The Plextor 740 and the BenQ 1640 are basically the same drives and show a totally different data set in your statistics ...

Another thing to consider - AFAIK there are 3 totally different SONY DVD-ROM DDU1621 drives (you can distinguish them by firmware version notation). Generally it would be usefull to split drives by firmware versions - firmware can affect ripping accuracy.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #14 – 2006-06-21 04:36:34

Quote

Drive: PLEXTOR - CD-R PX-W2410A (40 users): 5774 Accurate Submissions 6912
Inaccurate 45%

Does this include tracks ripped with EAC?

A few months ago, I ripped about 2500 tracks with this drive (with accuraterip & EAC). A significant amount (>60%) of the CDs were not in the database.

It might be interesting to see the statistics with not-in-database and all-tracks-failed (diff. pressing) discarded.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #15 – 2006-06-25 14:42:05

Awesome ! Thank you very much for this productive compilation, Spoon !!!

I'd like to suggest something:

1. Let's make this thread a sticky, as this list is of general interest for nearly everyone here on this
board and especially everyone, who is going to purchase a new CD drive, and doesn't know which
one to choose.

2. If compiling this list is not involved with too much effort, how about releasing such a list 2 times in
a year ? I really appreciate this list and am totally happy about it ^^ ...

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #16 – 2006-06-25 23:01:48

It took 1 day of computer crunching (and HD) to generate, so wouldnt like to run it more than twice a year.

Next time I will try to remove results where the cd is not in the database (but these really should be uniformly spread amongst drives).

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #17 – 2008-04-20 14:01:36

Thanks spoon for sharing this information. Really interesting thread.

But nearly two years went by and maybe a few million more tracks ripped since then. Would it be possible to update the list or make a new one? That would really be great!

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #18 – 2008-04-22 16:37:10

I will see if I can re-run it.

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #19 – 2008-04-22 17:00:39

Quote from: spoon on 2008-04-22 16:37:10

I will see if I can re-run it.

Yes, it is certain to be illuminating!

-brendan

CD Drive Accuracy List

Reply #20 – 2008-04-27 15:13:07

A new list would be great.

Could I get some opinions on which of my drives I should use as a reader/ripper?

BenQ 1640
Samsung SH-S203B
LG HL-DT-ST GSA-H62N

Based on reviews, I would think that the Samsung (C2 error capable) would be best. But after looking at this (old) list. Maybe the BenQ is the safest bet.

Notice