AAC at 128kbps test - FINISHED |
AAC at 128kbps test - FINISHED |
Jun 16 2003, 08:12
Post
#1
|
|
![]() Rarewares admin Group: Members Posts: 7515 Joined: 30-September 01 From: Brazil Member No.: 81 |
I'd like to announce that my first listening test successfuly ended.
The results page is available here: http://rarewares.hydrogenaudio.org/test/aa...st/results.html (veteran forum members will notice that page resembles to someone else's) So far, you only get results for each sample, and overall results. Tomorrow, I'll add fancy things like user comments, bitrates, etc. If someone notices flaws or typos, please report in this thread or through PM. Thanks a lot. (Also, info on the 41_30sec sample is welcome) For those really hurried, here is the overall plot: ![]() Once again, thanks to everyone that participated. Hopefully, there'll be more in a month. Kind regards; Roberto Amorim. -------------------- Get up-to-date binaries of Lame, AAC, Vorbis and much more at RareWares:
http://www.rarewares.org |
|
|
|
rjamorim AAC at 128kbps test - FINISHED Jun 16 2003, 08:12
sven_Bent wow
QT really shines wonder how it compares to psy... Jun 16 2003, 08:35
ChrisGranger Just a little typo in the last line: "Sorenso... Jun 16 2003, 08:39
ilikedirtthe2nd QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun 16 2003 - 07:12 AM)(Als... Jun 16 2003, 08:50
dev0 Very interesting, especially considering how bad D... Jun 16 2003, 08:54
den I am also interested to see how aacenc -streaming ... Jun 16 2003, 08:55
Ivan Dimkovic QUOTE I am also interested to see how aacenc -stre... Jun 16 2003, 09:24
Dalkus Interesting results. Does this test say anything a... Jun 16 2003, 09:32
guruboolez QUOTE (den @ Jun 16 2003 - 08:55 AM)I am also... Jun 16 2003, 09:36
bawjaws minor nitpick with track info:
It should be ... Jun 16 2003, 11:11
Paspro What I find strange is the difference between the ... Jun 16 2003, 11:32
guruboolez QUOTE (Paspro @ Jun 16 2003 - 11:32 AM)Still,... Jun 16 2003, 11:37
Paspro QUOTE (guruboolez @ Jun 16 2003 - 02:37 AM)QU... Jun 16 2003, 11:58
guruboolez QUOTE (Paspro @ Jun 16 2003 - 11:58 AM)Hmm...... Jun 16 2003, 12:06
ff123 Nice test, Roberto.
A few comments:
1. I think ... Jun 16 2003, 12:08
Garf ff123,
What do you think about 'eyeballing... Jun 16 2003, 12:13
Paspro QUOTE (guruboolez @ Jun 16 2003 - 03:06 AM)QU... Jun 16 2003, 12:13
ff123 QUOTE (Garf @ Jun 16 2003 - 03:13 AM)ff123,
... Jun 16 2003, 12:26
Cobra Maybe compare AAC and Ogg Vorbis (both GT3b1 and l... Jun 16 2003, 12:55
dev0 QUOTE (Cobra @ Jun 16 2003 - 12:55 PM)Maybe c... Jun 16 2003, 13:01
Garf I would definetly _not_ use any of the tuned Vorbi... Jun 16 2003, 13:09
guruboolez QUOTE (Garf @ Jun 16 2003 - 01:09 PM)I would ... Jun 16 2003, 13:28
feces1223 Yeah I'd Never Expect QT to come in as top cuz... Jun 16 2003, 13:33
Garf QUOTE (guruboolez @ Jun 16 2003 - 02:28 PM)QU... Jun 16 2003, 13:35
guruboolez QUOTE (Garf @ Jun 16 2003 - 01:35 PM)Yes, but... Jun 16 2003, 14:07
dev0 I can only support Guru's comment: GT2's 1... Jun 16 2003, 15:15
guruboolez QUOTE (dev0 @ Jun 16 2003 - 03:15 PM)Maybe th... Jun 16 2003, 15:41
treech AACenc = Sorenson ? Jun 16 2003, 16:06
guruboolez QUOTE (treech @ Jun 16 2003 - 04:06 PM)AACenc... Jun 16 2003, 16:08
treech ahh, ok thanks
also, would interresting to se if/... Jun 16 2003, 16:20
ff123 Quick and dirty new analysis, in response to compl... Jun 16 2003, 16:25
guruboolez Back to some results.
I'm really surprised to... Jun 16 2003, 16:36
ckjnigel Thanks to Roberto and know that my admiration cont... Jun 16 2003, 16:53
Ivan Dimkovic Guruboolez, ask Menno for the internal NERO plu... Jun 16 2003, 17:06
rjamorim QUOTE (ChrisGranger @ Jun 16 2003 - 04:39 AM)... Jun 16 2003, 18:21
rjamorim QUOTE (ilikedirtthe2nd @ Jun 16 2003 - 04:50 ... Jun 16 2003, 18:24
rjamorim QUOTE (bawjaws @ Jun 16 2003 - 07:11 AM)minor... Jun 16 2003, 18:32
rjamorim QUOTE (Paspro @ Jun 16 2003 - 07:32 AM)So, wh... Jun 16 2003, 18:35
rjamorim
Well, Lizst and Bach were removed because people ... Jun 16 2003, 19:03
NickSD QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun 16 2003 - 10:24 AM)Than... Jun 16 2003, 19:06
Garf QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun 16 2003 - 08:03 PM)Well... Jun 16 2003, 19:09
niktheblak QUOTE (guruboolez @ Jun 16 2003 - 05:36 PM)Ca... Jun 16 2003, 19:36
rjamorim QUOTE (ckjnigel @ Jun 16 2003 - 12:53 PM)1) A... Jun 16 2003, 19:42
guruboolez QUOTE (niktheblak @ Jun 16 2003 - 07:36 PM)QU... Jun 16 2003, 19:50
ff123 QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun 16 2003 - 10:03 AM)QUOT... Jun 16 2003, 20:43
ff123 Regarding 41_30sec.wav
QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun... Jun 16 2003, 20:49
ErikS Does ANOVA take into consideration the varying sca... Jun 16 2003, 21:34
Agent86 Does anyone know anything about the AAC codec that... Jun 16 2003, 21:58
rjamorim XM is probably using gear from Thales
http://www.t... Jun 16 2003, 22:13
Differenciam Very interesting. I'm quite disappointed in N... Jun 16 2003, 22:48
Agent86 QUOTE Thales uses AAC encoder from FhG and SBR enc... Jun 16 2003, 22:59
ff123 QUOTE (ErikS @ Jun 16 2003 - 12:34 PM)Does AN... Jun 17 2003, 04:52
rjamorim I updated the overall graph, following a suggestio... Jun 17 2003, 04:58
den Thanks again for organising this most useful test ... Jun 17 2003, 05:39
rjamorim QUOTE (den @ Jun 17 2003 - 01:39 AM)Based on ... Jun 17 2003, 07:14
lazyn00b QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun 16 2003 - 10:14 PM)For ... Jun 17 2003, 09:09
guruboolez We can consider the possibility, for the next test... Jun 17 2003, 10:10
JohnV QUOTE (guruboolez @ Jun 17 2003 - 12:10 PM)We... Jun 17 2003, 11:26
dev0 QUOTE I'm also wondering if MPC is necessary f... Jun 17 2003, 11:40
Garf Excluding MPC makes no sense - it's definetely... Jun 17 2003, 12:01
guruboolez QUOTE (Garf @ Jun 17 2003 - 12:01 PM)Excludin... Jun 17 2003, 12:20
JohnV QUOTE (Garf @ Jun 17 2003 - 02:01 PM)Excludin... Jun 17 2003, 12:42
Garf I don't get it. Why should we include Vorbis t... Jun 17 2003, 13:10
JohnV QUOTE (Garf @ Jun 17 2003 - 03:10 PM)I don... Jun 17 2003, 13:23
Garf QUOTE (JohnV @ Jun 17 2003 - 02:23 PM)and mos... Jun 17 2003, 13:27
JohnV QUOTE (Garf @ Jun 17 2003 - 03:27 PM)But you ... Jun 17 2003, 13:56
ErikS Just to chime in with Garf... MPC is used by exact... Jun 17 2003, 14:56
JohnV QUOTE (ErikS @ Jun 17 2003 - 04:56 PM)Just to... Jun 17 2003, 15:03
ErikS QUOTE (JohnV @ Jun 17 2003 - 03:03 PM)As far ... Jun 17 2003, 15:10
den The objectives of this test are not that clear, at... Jun 17 2003, 15:58
rjamorim Wow. I wake up, and there's almost a format wa... Jun 17 2003, 17:20
pierugg What about MP3Pro ?? Jun 17 2003, 20:05
floyd There isn't much point testing mp3pro at 128kp... Jun 17 2003, 20:30
SometimesWarrior I'd like to better understand the purpose of t... Jun 17 2003, 20:56
rjamorim MP3pro isn't considered good above 96kbps. The... Jun 17 2003, 21:33
ff123 Here's a comment from the masses:
http://grou... Jun 18 2003, 03:53
chf Sorry, Is there any one try to compare ODG of thes... Jun 18 2003, 04:29
tangent It would be nice to see MPC @128kbps added to the ... Jun 18 2003, 05:47
ajp The result of the test has been posted here as wel... Jun 18 2003, 08:31
SometimesWarrior QUOTE (chf @ Jun 17 2003 - 08:29 PM)Sorry, Is... Jun 18 2003, 09:01
SometimesWarrior QUOTE (ajp @ Jun 18 2003 - 12:31 AM)The resul... Jun 18 2003, 09:12
Paspro QUOTE (ckjnigel @ Jun 16 2003 - 07:53 AM)2) W... Jun 18 2003, 10:24
Paspro QUOTE (ajp @ Jun 17 2003 - 11:31 PM)The resul... Jun 18 2003, 10:30
loophole Nice board
I would just like to point out to any... Jun 18 2003, 13:50
rjamorim QUOTE (SometimesWarrior @ Jun 18 2003 - 05:01... Jun 18 2003, 15:03
guruboolez In order to clarify the challengers for the second... Jun 18 2003, 15:04
rjamorim QUOTE (loophole @ Jun 18 2003 - 09:50 AM)I wo... Jun 18 2003, 15:07
Paspro QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun 18 2003 - 06:07 AM)QUOT... Jun 18 2003, 15:27
guruboolez Tested (quickly) GT2 vs Post CVS release of ogg vo... Jun 18 2003, 16:24
loophole QUOTE (Paspro @ Jun 18 2003 - 06:27 AM)QUOTE ... Jun 18 2003, 16:38
rjamorim QUOTE (loophole @ Jun 18 2003 - 12:38 PM)That... Jun 18 2003, 16:53
rjamorim QUOTE (ff123 @ Jun 17 2003 - 11:53 PM)Here... Jun 18 2003, 16:59
Paspro QUOTE (rjamorim @ Jun 18 2003 - 07:53 AM)QUOT... Jun 18 2003, 17:12
Paspro Ok, I encoded an AIFF file with QuickTime 6.3 and ... Jun 18 2003, 18:49
brett i did a quick encode of one 6+ minute track in itu... Jun 18 2003, 20:46
bawjaws QUOTE (Paspro @ Jun 18 2003 - 09:49 AM)Ok, I ... Jun 18 2003, 22:28
rjamorim QUOTE (bawjaws @ Jun 18 2003 - 06:28 PM)In pa... Jun 18 2003, 23:42
ff123 It might make it easier to compare if you decode t... Jun 18 2003, 23:52
Paspro QUOTE (bawjaws @ Jun 18 2003 - 01:28 PM)QUOTE... Jun 18 2003, 23:55
loophole QUOTE (Paspro @ Jun 18 2003 - 02:55 PM)QUOTE ... Jun 19 2003, 01:57![]() ![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 25th May 2013 - 04:12 |