Extract HDCD, How I Can extract HDCD by software? Options

[SCIF]

How I Can extract HDCD by software(EAC, WMP9...)?

[SebastianG]

One could modify the decoder to output 24 bit samples where the least significant 4 bits are zero (effective resolution: 20 bits) so it'll compress better using FLAC and/or WavPack.

Since the HDCD decoder attenuates the signal at most by 13.5 dB which translates to 2.25 bits, you won't need more than 20 bits to represent the signal faithfully. So quantizing to 20 bits makes sense and won't hurt (won't effect the noise floor noticably).

Still, what's the point on decoding for lossless storage? Guys! Think about it. I'd keep the 16 bit signal as is and use a HDCD capable player instead!

Interesting result this, the 24bit HDCD decoded version compresses to a size even smaller than the original 16bit.

...which can only mean that your CD doesn't make use of all HDCD features (no "soft dynamics compression").


Cheers!
SG

This post has been edited by SebastianG: Aug 27 2007, 18:23

[SiriusB]

One could modify the decoder to output 24 bit samples where the least significant 4 bits are zero (effective resolution: 20 bits) so it'll compress better using FLAC and/or WavPack.

Since the HDCD decoder attenuates the signal at most by 13.5 dB which translates to 2.25 bits, you won't need more than 20 bits to represent the signal faithfully. So quantizing to 20 bits makes sense and won't hurt (won't effect the noise floor noticably).

Still, what's the point on decoding for lossless storage? Guys! Think about it. I'd keep the 16 bit signal as is and use a HDCD capable player instead!

Hi guys, great thread. I found it earlier and have been posting a lot to the Hoffman forum about my findings, using both the WMP plugin and hdcd.exe.

As for not using lossless storage, that means storing them as 16-bit WAVs; the only HDCD software player I know is player is WMP, which does not recognize wavs as HDCD. You either have to play an actual disc, or mount a virtual one, for WMP to recognize it at HDCD.

Or are you thinking of some other mechanism?


Regarding the two software decoders, I find that they produce almost identical results - I ripped a Joni Mitchell HDCD to my drive with EAC, then mounted it with Daemon tools for WMP (with the WAV plugin and 24-bit playback active), or else fed the .wavs to hdcd.exe. FOr a given track the two resulting .wav files almost null out, though there is tiny, residual signal at -88 dBFS or so, at a few spots (bit comparison with foobar says there are something like ~700 nonidentical samples, in one track, for example). I couldn't tell them apart in an ABX.

Regarding final bit depths, I find that the HDCDs which do NOT use peak extension, and which are highly compressed/limited, so far always decode to '17 bit' files , reduced by 6 dB (examples: Beck and Van Halen HDCDs). THose that use peak extend decode to 20 bit files (e.g. Yes, Joni Mitchell), though some that have no apparent peak extension, but are not super compressed dynamically, also decode to 20 bit files (e.g. King Crimson), with lesser amounts of level reduction. see this post for examples.

Lastly, I find that foobar2000 (v 0.9.4.4) cannot play decoded files made by the WMP plugin (which appear to be in 'wavex' format, and elicit a WAVEXTENSIBLE tag from flac.exe when I compress them) wheras it can play the 24 bit files produced by hdcd.exe, and flacs made from them. Unlike the older foobar, the newer one doesn't have options for setting playback bit depth, as best I can tell.


All feedback appreciated! I'm especially interested to know if the 'low resolution extension' and selectable filter options are actually used by either decoder (I've also got a hardware HDCD player and plan to compare its analog output to the digital 'rips')

I'll have a go tomorrow at adding some more diagnostics, maybe a --verbose option, which will list which features get used after the track's been processed. I'd guess:

Peak extend enabled at some point during the audio
Peak extend disabled at some point during the audio
Peak extend used (|sample|>0x5980 while peak extend used)
Range of gain adjustment values used.

From what I've read (e.g. John Marks' self-interview about his HDCD releases) it appears that the HDCD A/D converter adds the flag that will activate the HDCD logo even if NONE of the processing options are used during the mastering...in other words, if 'HDCD' technology us just used for its high-quality A/D conversion. So WMP would light up the HDCD logo, but simply attenuate these by 6 dB, as it does for all input when the 24 bit option is active (I recall this being a mandate from Pacific Microsonics originally).

This post has been edited by SiriusB: Aug 30 2007, 03:40