XLD - ripper now disables cache and supports AccurateRip
Reply #10 – 2008-08-21 05:46:53
I just ran a test run on a previously ripped with cdparanoia and checked with an arcue.pl spin off. Everything came out as accurate except for the first and last tracks. I then checked the output again with arcue and all tracks came up accurate, including the first and last. So I suspect an issue with the first and last few samples that are supposed to be thrown away by Accurate Rip. Other than that, very nice. Certainly easier than the cdparanoia / cdrdao / arcue script I've been using. Problems in choosing the right address to multiply against the sample and/or forgetting to omit the first 5 frames of the first track and the last 5 frames of the last track? Combined with doubts concerning the ability to flush cache, it looks like the air is deflating pretty quickly. I have not had that problem with XLD's AccurateRip reporting. Using a Pioneer DVD-RW DVR-108 (offset +48), I have been getting accurate rips on all tracks. Below is the log output of the disc I just finished ripping. Note the confidence levels. The cache issue may still be up in the air, but after ripping over 20 discs so far with XLD, I'm more than reasonably satisfied that it plays nice with AccurateRip.XLD extraction logfile from 2008-08-20 23:11:36 -0500 Can / Tago Mago Used drive : PIONEER DVD-RW DVR-108 (revision 1.17) Use cdparanoia mode : YES Disable audio cache : YES Read offset correction : 48 Max retry count : 100 TOC of the extracted CD Track | Start | Length | Start sector | End sector --------------------------------------------------------- 1 | 00:00:32 | 07:28:00 | 32 | 33631 2 | 07:28:32 | 04:03:03 | 33632 | 51859 3 | 11:31:35 | 07:24:37 | 51860 | 85196 4 | 18:55:72 | 18:28:10 | 85197 | 168306 5 | 37:24:07 | 17:33:38 | 168307 | 247319 6 | 54:57:45 | 11:38:02 | 247320 | 299671 7 | 66:35:47 | 06:45:73 | 299672 | 330119 Track 01 Filename : /Users/x/Desktop/Can Tago Mago/01 Can - Paperhouse.wav CRC32 hash : 1ADEFF0C CRC32 hash (EAC style) : E7E7924C AccurateRip signature : B222CBBD ->Accurately ripped! (confidence 10) Statistics Read error : 0 Skipped (treated as error) : 0 Edge jitter error (fixed) : 0 Atom jitter error (fixed) : 0 Dropped bytes error (fixed) : 0 Duplicated bytes error (fixed) : 0 Track 02 Filename : /Users/x/Desktop/Can Tago Mago/02 Can - Mushroom.wav CRC32 hash : CBE7CD2E CRC32 hash (EAC style) : 5E237342 AccurateRip signature : C02D63BD ->Accurately ripped! (confidence 10) Statistics Read error : 0 Skipped (treated as error) : 0 Edge jitter error (fixed) : 0 Atom jitter error (fixed) : 0 Dropped bytes error (fixed) : 0 Duplicated bytes error (fixed) : 0 Track 03 Filename : /Users/x/Desktop/Can Tago Mago/03 Can - Oh Yeah.wav CRC32 hash : DAE43DCF CRC32 hash (EAC style) : 06EE8AED AccurateRip signature : 128C51DC ->Accurately ripped! (confidence 11) Statistics Read error : 0 Skipped (treated as error) : 0 Edge jitter error (fixed) : 0 Atom jitter error (fixed) : 0 Dropped bytes error (fixed) : 0 Duplicated bytes error (fixed) : 0 Track 04 Filename : /Users/x/Desktop/Can Tago Mago/04 Can - Halleluhwah.wav CRC32 hash : 3225FEBC CRC32 hash (EAC style) : 0659F2FE AccurateRip signature : 3FC649A4 ->Accurately ripped! (confidence 10) Statistics Read error : 0 Skipped (treated as error) : 0 Edge jitter error (fixed) : 0 Atom jitter error (fixed) : 0 Dropped bytes error (fixed) : 0 Duplicated bytes error (fixed) : 0 Track 05 Filename : /Users/x/Desktop/Can Tago Mago/05 Can - Aumgn.wav CRC32 hash : 42BA58B7 CRC32 hash (EAC style) : A0588DE6 AccurateRip signature : FF895D23 ->Accurately ripped! (confidence 10) Statistics Read error : 0 Skipped (treated as error) : 0 Edge jitter error (fixed) : 0 Atom jitter error (fixed) : 0 Dropped bytes error (fixed) : 0 Duplicated bytes error (fixed) : 0 Track 06 Filename : /Users/x/Desktop/Can Tago Mago/06 Can - Peking O.wav CRC32 hash : E1D5B39F CRC32 hash (EAC style) : 939B1844 AccurateRip signature : FB6B0DD1 ->Accurately ripped! (confidence 8) Statistics Read error : 0 Skipped (treated as error) : 0 Edge jitter error (fixed) : 0 Atom jitter error (fixed) : 0 Dropped bytes error (fixed) : 0 Duplicated bytes error (fixed) : 0 Track 07 Filename : /Users/x/Desktop/Can Tago Mago/07 Can - Bring Me Coffee Or Tea.wav CRC32 hash : 74CF3981 CRC32 hash (EAC style) : 19DC8942 AccurateRip signature : BF75ABF6 ->Accurately ripped! (confidence 9) Statistics Read error : 0 Skipped (treated as error) : 0 Edge jitter error (fixed) : 0 Atom jitter error (fixed) : 0 Dropped bytes error (fixed) : 0 Duplicated bytes error (fixed) : 0 No errors occurred End of status report This is typical of the results I've been getting since installing XLD last night. Works for me. XLD is now my ripper of choice. Cache flushing or not, it is thus far the only Mac ripper that utilizes AccurateRip, and that puts it ahead of anything else that's currently available. And did I mention the log? The best log implementation I've ever seen on a Mac ripper. Thanks to ffooky for bringing this to my attention. [!--sizeo:1--][span style=\"font-size:8pt;line-height:100%\"][!--/sizeo--]Moderation: Please use a codebox. [/size]