Public AAC Listening Test @ ~96 kbps [July 2011]: Results, Results and post-test discussion |
Public AAC Listening Test @ ~96 kbps [July 2011]: Results, Results and post-test discussion |
Aug 23 2011, 19:56
Post
#1
|
|
|
Group: Members Posts: 1315 Joined: 3-January 05 From: Argentina, Bs As Member No.: 18803 |
After the long time of preparations, discussions and realization of the test the results are finally here.
http://listening-tests.hydrogenaudio.org/i...-a/results.html Summary: Apple won, FhG is the second, Coding Technologies is the third and Nero is the last I appreciate all people who has supported the test and participated in it. This post has been edited by IgorC: Aug 23 2011, 20:12 |
|
|
|
![]() |
Oct 23 2011, 07:14
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Members Posts: 1315 Joined: 3-January 05 From: Argentina, Bs As Member No.: 18803 |
Late but still here.
Some participants have answered a few questions. 16 persons. Gender: 15 - male 1 - female Age (years): Min – 20 Max – 50 Average – 28.53 Headphones/loudspeakers: 15 persons - headphones 1 person - loudspeakers Headphones Sennheiser (HD 280pro, 650, 600, CX500), Razer Moray+, Beyerdynamic (DT800), heco victa 300 stereo speakers, Panasonic RP-HC500, Creative EP-630 earphones, Audio-Technica ATH-M50, Grados SR80, Sony MDR-V150 Headphones, Technics RP-8801 ... Soundcard: On-board – 6 persons Not on-board – 10 persons Creative X-Fi Xtreme Gamer, 82801H (ICH8 Family) HD Audio Controller (rev 03), Apogee Duet interface, on-board VIA HD (on the Asus P7P55D Pro), creative x-fi, Creative Audigy 4, Realtek ALC888, Little Dot Mk IV headphone amp running from M-Audiophile 24/96 soundcard, Realtek internal soundcard on laptop + FiiO E7 DAC/Amp, Realtek ALC887, ... On-board soundcards are fine. Nowdays on-board solutions are actually very good. Operating System: Win7 – 53.3% WinXP – 20% Linux – 20% MAC - 6.7% Computer: PC – 57% Notebook – 43% The noise of fans (aproxímate data): Less or more – 50% Low – 43% High – 7% Quite room?: Yes – 86% No – 14% Time of testing: Morning – 15% Afternoon – 18.3% Evening – 50.7% Night - 16% The place (room): Home – 82% Data Sever/ Computer room or Office – 18% Previous participation in public tests: 9 persons – it was a first time. 2 persons – 1 previous public test. 5 persons – 4-5 or more previous public tests. This post has been edited by IgorC: Oct 23 2011, 07:51 |
|
|
|
IgorC Public AAC Listening Test @ ~96 kbps [July 2011]: Results Aug 23 2011, 19:56
benski It would be interesting to do a rank-sum analysis ... Aug 23 2011, 20:18
Garf QUOTE (benski @ Aug 23 2011, 21:18) It wo... Aug 23 2011, 20:27

benski QUOTE (Garf @ Aug 23 2011, 15:27) QUOTE (... Aug 23 2011, 20:54

Garf QUOTE (benski @ Aug 23 2011, 21:54) The F... Aug 23 2011, 21:11
C.R.Helmrich QUOTE (benski @ Aug 23 2011, 21:18) ... w... Aug 23 2011, 20:42

Garf QUOTE (C.R.Helmrich @ Aug 23 2011, 21:42)... Aug 23 2011, 20:47


lvqcl QUOTE (Garf @ Aug 23 2011, 23:47) Basical... Aug 27 2011, 20:22


no404error QUOTE (lvqcl @ Aug 27 2011, 22:22) CVBR, ... Sep 4 2011, 04:01

benski QUOTE (C.R.Helmrich @ Aug 23 2011, 15:42)... Aug 23 2011, 20:52
IgorC QUOTE (benski @ Aug 23 2011, 16:18) It wo... Aug 23 2011, 21:01
benski QUOTE (IgorC @ Aug 23 2011, 16:01) QUOTE ... Aug 23 2011, 21:07
IgorC QUOTE (benski @ Aug 23 2011, 17:07) Actua... Aug 23 2011, 21:11
IgorC I should also mention that I've participated i... Aug 23 2011, 21:30
zima Maybe there could be a legend for X-axis, the abbr... Aug 23 2011, 21:37
lvqcl It is interesting that QT tvbr and cvbr encoded fi... Aug 23 2011, 22:05
IgorC zima,
will fix it later.
QUOTE (lvqcl @ Au... Aug 23 2011, 22:11
Alexxander Thanks to all who participated in this test and to... Aug 23 2011, 22:31
Garf QUOTE (Alexxander @ Aug 23 2011, 23:31) I... Aug 23 2011, 23:02
Dakeryas Many thanks for the test !
Interesting to not... Aug 23 2011, 23:11
IgorC I've noticed that previous version of Nero 1.0... Aug 23 2011, 23:51
Gornot To be perfectly honest, I am surprised that FhG di... Aug 24 2011, 00:29
/mnt Interesting results, I gotta see if the pre-echo h... Aug 24 2011, 01:23
kennedyb4 If it is fair to say that many of the samples were... Aug 24 2011, 01:42
Sebastian Mares It appears to me that the low anchor was way too b... Aug 24 2011, 07:29
Garf QUOTE (Sebastian Mares @ Aug 24 2011, 08... Aug 24 2011, 09:35
Nezmer QUOTE (Garf @ Aug 24 2011, 10:35) Probabl... Aug 24 2011, 11:35
Garf QUOTE (Nezmer @ Aug 24 2011, 12:35) QUOTE... Aug 24 2011, 12:46
Nezmer QUOTE (Garf @ Aug 24 2011, 13:46) QUOTE (... Aug 24 2011, 18:26
greynol I was wondering the same thing. Aug 24 2011, 07:49
C.R.Helmrich Some bit-rate statistics which were presented in p... Aug 24 2011, 18:27
Garf QUOTE (C.R.Helmrich @ Aug 24 2011, 19:27)... Aug 25 2011, 07:29
Zarggg Just looking for a quick verification on whether I... Aug 25 2011, 18:06
IgorC QUOTE (Zarggg @ Aug 25 2011, 14:06) Am I ... Aug 25 2011, 18:28
greynol CVBR and TVBR are statistically tied. One did not... Aug 25 2011, 18:12
Zarggg QUOTE (greynol @ Aug 25 2011, 13:12) CVBR... Aug 25 2011, 22:47
Garf QUOTE (greynol @ Aug 25 2011, 19:12) CVBR... Aug 26 2011, 07:20
greynol That assumes facts not in evidence. Aug 25 2011, 19:04
Gecko First, thank you IgorC and everyone involved!
... Aug 25 2011, 20:24
IgorC QUOTE (Gecko @ Aug 25 2011, 16:24) First,... Aug 26 2011, 03:30

mjb2006 QUOTE (IgorC @ Aug 25 2011, 20:30) I do n... Aug 26 2011, 05:18

IgorC QUOTE (mjb2006 @ Aug 26 2011, 01:18) Anyw... Aug 26 2011, 05:24
Garf QUOTE (Gecko @ Aug 25 2011, 21:24) a) Do ... Aug 26 2011, 07:16
IgorC QUOTE (Garf @ Aug 26 2011, 03:16) Always ... Aug 26 2011, 08:51
mjb2006 Even though I sent in results, they didn't get... Aug 25 2011, 22:50
Gecko Thank you IgorC and Garf for answering my question... Aug 26 2011, 10:28
IgorC QUOTE (Gecko @ Aug 26 2011, 06:28) Given ... Aug 26 2011, 11:20

Garf QUOTE (IgorC @ Aug 26 2011, 12:20) QUOTE ... Aug 27 2011, 17:48
Garf QUOTE (Gecko @ Aug 26 2011, 11:28) In the... Aug 27 2011, 17:39
IgorC I found the first and the last graphs to be partic... Aug 27 2011, 21:46
lvqcl QUOTE (IgorC @ Aug 28 2011, 00:46) I thin... Aug 27 2011, 22:20
IgorC Yeah Aug 27 2011, 22:39
IgorC BTW if someone want to organize the next public te... Oct 1 2011, 20:21
jukkap How about 48kbps HE AAC ? Or low bitrate multiform... Oct 1 2011, 20:49
IgorC QUOTE (jukkap @ Oct 1 2011, 16:49) How ab... Oct 10 2011, 23:17
jukkap QUOTE (IgorC @ Oct 10 2011, 23:17) The la... Oct 20 2011, 10:04
IgorC Well, the last time we have tested LC-AAC encoders... Oct 1 2011, 21:58
jukkap QUOTE (IgorC @ Oct 1 2011, 22:58) Can You... Oct 2 2011, 05:10![]() ![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 25th May 2013 - 15:46 |