IPB

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

TransPCM—use Float16/24 to reduce bit-depth, also promotes compression, 2013-05-30: beta 0.1.3a / formerly HalfPrecision / ref.: IEEE 754-2008
Nick.C
post Sep 12 2011, 22:03
Post #1


lossyWAV Developer


Group: Developer
Posts: 1772
Joined: 11-April 07
From: Wherever here is
Member No.: 42400



When I first became aware of the Float16 type I found it interesting in terms of maybe having potential as a possible lossy storage type.

Attached is a processed version of the sample in this thread which has been decoded back to PCM. The processing is as follows (at this stage as there is no player that I am aware of):
Input file Sample [PCM] > FLOAT16 > [PCM] > Output File.

The conversion from integer to Float16 reduces the number of significant bits of the 24-bit sample to (a maximum of) 11. There is therefore an amount of added noise due to truncation. The added noise has been noise shaped using SG's adaptive noise shaping method as used in lossyWAV.

Original Sample

Lossy Float16 Processed Sample [edit] removed due to TransPCM executable / foobar2000 Float16 playback availability, 29th May 2012. [/edit]

If the 24-bit coded sample is encoded with FLAC (wFormatTag left as 0x0001 as FLAC does not handle Floating Point samples and wBitsPerSample is left as 24) there is a saving of in excess of 20% in filesize.

I don't see any practical advantage using this storage type for native 16-bit PCM.

Changelog:

TransPCM beta 0.1.3a 30/05/2013
  • Bug fix in Float24 handling (thanks Bryant!).
  • Bug fix in WAVE_FORMAT_EXTENSIBLE chunk handling (thanks again Bryant!).
TransPCM beta 0.1.2 02/06/2012
  • Modification to adaptive noise shaping for 44.1/48kHz input;
  • Amendment to tracer fingerprinting.


This post has been edited by Nick.C: May 30 2013, 07:57
Attached File(s)
Attached File  TransPCM_beta_0.1.3a.zip ( 79.66K ) Number of downloads: 64
 


--------------------
lossyWAV -q X -a 4 --feedback 4| FLAC -8 ~= 320kbps
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
 
Start new topic
Replies
Nick.C
post Jan 9 2012, 20:05
Post #2


lossyWAV Developer


Group: Developer
Posts: 1772
Joined: 11-April 07
From: Wherever here is
Member No.: 42400



Hi there,

Using HalfPrecision to convert from 24-bit integer PCM to 16-bit floating point will add a small amount of noise to the output while at the same time reducing the uncompressed file-size by approximately one-third.

The lossless file, when downloaded, has no ReplayGain information. The lossy version has ReplayGain information appended (using the latest R128Gain in foobar2000). If new ReplayGain values are calculated for both files then you will find that they are within approximately 0.01dB of each other (+2.97dB and +2.98dB respectively).

I agree about the lack of lossless compression - I am quietly hoping that one of the lossless codec developers takes up the challenge. As I said previously, when an incorrect wFormatTag is used ($0001 for Integer rather than $0003 for Floating Point) then over 20% filesize saving is made compressing 16-bit FP-PCM instead of 24-bit Int-PCM.

This is not really a codec - rather an alternative representation of the audio data - (practically) no decoding is required by the playback software.

Nick.


--------------------
lossyWAV -q X -a 4 --feedback 4| FLAC -8 ~= 320kbps
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
- Nick.C   TransPCM—use Float16/24 to reduce bit-depth, also promotes compression   Sep 12 2011, 22:03
- - AndyH-ha   This differs from simply reducing the bit depth?   Sep 12 2011, 22:11
- - Nick.C   Yes - in that values up to c. +/- 2^31 can still b...   Sep 12 2011, 22:19
- - saratoga   Isn't this pretty much what ADPCM does? Excep...   Sep 12 2011, 22:32
|- - C.R.Helmrich   You mean a-Law/µ-Law? Makes me wonder how many bi...   Sep 12 2011, 23:05
- - bryant   QUOTE (Nick.C @ Sep 12 2011, 14:03) Attac...   Sep 13 2011, 06:13
- - Nick.C   The plan was to simply set wFormatTag= 0x0003 and ...   Sep 15 2011, 21:09
|- - benski   QUOTE (Nick.C @ Sep 15 2011, 16:09) The p...   Sep 16 2011, 14:03
- - knutinh   float16 could be very efficient on GPU hardware if...   Sep 16 2011, 13:49
- - Nick.C   I understand that currently players are rather unl...   Sep 16 2011, 19:26
- - Nick.C   Below is Delphi / IA32 & x87 code used to enco...   Sep 22 2011, 13:05
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.0.2cd attached. [bugfix] [sup...   Oct 20 2011, 12:53
|- - Gumboot   QUOTE (Nick.C @ Oct 20 2011, 11:53) NB: t...   Dec 22 2011, 23:19
- - lvqcl   foobar2000 1.1.9 beta1: "Implemented experime...   Oct 22 2011, 10:54
- - Nick.C   RE: TransPCM—use Float16/24 to reduce bit-depth, also promotes compression   Oct 22 2011, 14:24
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.0.2e attached [superseded]. F...   Oct 24 2011, 18:23
- - pdq   I once had an idea for how to encode audio data. T...   Oct 24 2011, 19:29
- - Nick.C   That would be one way of doing it. However sample ...   Oct 24 2011, 21:02
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.0.2f attached superseded . ...   Nov 1 2011, 13:53
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.0.2g attached. Superseded. ...   Nov 10 2011, 13:41
- - Didjeridoo   Nick.C Thank you for your innovation. It remains t...   Nov 11 2011, 11:36
- - Nick.C   @Didjeridoo: Thanks - I am also looking forward to...   Nov 11 2011, 23:05
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.0.2h attached. Superseded ...   Nov 14 2011, 21:22
- - Didjeridoo   Nick.C I watch all the moves and develops Is not...   Nov 15 2011, 10:32
|- - lvqcl   QUOTE (Didjeridoo @ Nov 15 2011, 13:32) P...   Nov 15 2011, 15:53
- - Ljubo44   Do you have any sample of command line for foobar.   Nov 15 2011, 19:13
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.0.2i attached. Superseded. F...   Nov 15 2011, 20:05
- - Ljubo44   on 16/44,1 size is same after compress halfp.wav 1...   Nov 15 2011, 21:24
|- - Nick.C   QUOTE (Ljubo44 @ Nov 15 2011, 20:24) .......   Nov 15 2011, 22:05
- - Ljubo44   You are right, I used foobar 1.1.9 to convert to f...   Nov 15 2011, 22:37
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.0.2j attached. Superseded. ...   Nov 15 2011, 23:02
- - Nick.C   HalfPrecision beta 0.1.0a attached. Superseded. ...   Nov 17 2011, 14:20
- - Didjeridoo   I hope the developers do not ignore innovation   Nov 18 2011, 19:44
- - Nick.C   foobar2000 1.1.10 beta 1 adds Float24 support - re...   Nov 18 2011, 21:24
- - pompon   QUOTE (Nick.C @ Sep 12 2011, 16:03) When ...   Dec 5 2011, 06:37
- - FreaqyFrequency   @pompon: This is different from those coding sche...   Dec 5 2011, 08:44
- - Nick.C   Right then people - HalfPrecision needs a new name...   Dec 22 2011, 20:34
- - Nick.C   .... a surprise, yes, however as the standard has ...   Dec 23 2011, 08:20
|- - Gumboot   Well, by "huge surprise" I mean "de...   Dec 23 2011, 08:43
|- - Nick.C   It would surprise me if, when using any type of fl...   Dec 23 2011, 09:01
|- - Gumboot   Well it's not really in its infancy. I includ...   Dec 23 2011, 22:02
- - Nick.C   I accept that the Float16 proposal must have been ...   Dec 27 2011, 21:34
- - FreaqyFrequency   I fear that I may need a little more clarification...   Jan 9 2012, 05:48
- - Nick.C   Hi there, Using HalfPrecision to convert from 24-...   Jan 9 2012, 20:05
- - FreaqyFrequency   Thanks for the reply, Nick. Looking at the Replay...   Jan 10 2012, 03:36
- - Nick.C   TransPCM beta v0.1.1 attached. Superseded Chang...   May 29 2012, 21:51
- - Nick.C   TransPCM beta 0.1.2 attached. Superseded. Chang...   Jun 2 2012, 13:57
- - Ljubo44   CODE/d /c C:\bin\TransPCM_beta_0.1.2...   Jun 14 2012, 01:29
|- - lvqcl   QUOTE (Ljubo44 @ Jun 14 2012, 04:29) What...   Jun 14 2012, 15:47
- - db1989   Why do you have switches before the executable? An...   Jun 14 2012, 09:02
- - Nick.C   The use of --stdinname %d is to tell the program w...   Jun 14 2012, 17:47
- - Nick.C   Rockbox now has added Float16 compatibility* - tha...   Nov 24 2012, 23:15
- - saratoga   No problem. Hope its useful to people.   Nov 25 2012, 00:28
- - Nick.C   TransPCM beta 0.1.3a attached to post #1 in this t...   May 30 2013, 07:58


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 



RSS Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 17th April 2014 - 23:24