lame3100h, a functional extension
lame3100h, a functional extension
Dec 18 2012, 01:11
Joined: 9-October 05
From: Dormagen, Germany
Member No.: 25015
You can download it from here.
Whatís the functional extension?
It offers additional VBR quality settings -V5+ to -V0+ which cover the average bitrate range from ~144 to ~300 kbps (for a variety of pop music):
An alternative way to use the functional extension is --brV+ x, where x is the average bitrate (for a variety of pop music) you want to use. You can use for instance --brV+ 224 instead of -V2+.
What is it good for?
Lameís moderate VBR quality settings like -V5 or -V4 usually yield a very good quality. Thatís why many users are happy with these settings. Sometimes however tracks contain spots which are not encoded well. Many users want a better quality also for these rather rare events. From current experience Lame3.100 alpha2 seems to scale well quality of tonal problems with -Vn level, but temporal resolution can still be an issue.
-Vn+ uses -Vn as the encoding basis, but adds a certain amount of brute-force safety by forcing audio data bitrate to a target bitrate which depends on -Vn+ level. Moreover care is taken to always provide maximum possible audio data space for the encoding of short blocks which are used when the encoder thinks it is appropriate for a good temporal resolution. Also Lame's default lowpass is lowered a bit in order to make best use of the encoded bits (use --lowpass x if you don't like this).
Emphasis is on issues with temporal resolution, but tonal problems are tackled as well.
In a sense -Vn+ combines the quality advantages of both VBR and CBR.
Users who care much about filesize and are content with the functional extension improving short block (pre-echo) behavior, can use -V5+ to -V4+.
Users who donít like rather obvious issues in their music even when theyíre rare but who also care about filesize are best to choose from -V3.5+ to -V1.5+ according to their needs.
For a significant potential for improving tonal issues -V3+ or better is recommended.
Users who donít care much about filesize but much more about universal top quality are best served by using -V1+ or V0+, or anything in between.
lame3100h.exe was compiled with Visual C++ 2010. For this reason it is necessary to install the Microsoft Visual C++ 2010 Redistributable Package vcredist_x86.exe. You can download it from http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=8328
lame3100h.exe uses the fast and lossless mp3packer tool internally to squeeze the otherwise unused bits out of the mp3 file. You can download mp3packer from http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index....st&p=282289. Put mp3packer.exe into the same folder where lame3100h.exe is located. Many thanks to Omion for this great tool.
In case there is no mp3packer.exe in lame3100h.exeís folder lame3100h.exe will work, but the mp3 files will be somewhat larger than necessary.
This post has been edited by halb27: Dec 18 2012, 01:27
lame3100k -V0 --cvbr 9
Feb 25 2013, 14:49
Joined: 31-January 04
Member No.: 11664
I started to test 3.99.5 V1 V0+, 320k as well as the funtional extension builds (3995f). Quality is pretty good with both but unfortunately some problems remain and some are pretty bad.
Emese: Very bad quality up to V1/ V1+ and still not too good at V0/V0+. No benefit from the + settings. Tested 3100i - improvement. V0+ is still a bit noisy.
Florida Seq : To me its way worse than EIG. At 5.0 secs the smearing is so severe. I abx V0/V0+ 10/10 without listening to the reference. The + settings provide no benefit here. Edit: I tried again with 3100i: 7/10 then 10/10. I think there is an improvement but still a problem.
Angel falls 1st : Good progress with the + settings. Ringing is much reduced. + Settings have big impact here.
EIG: There is a click maybe around 3 secs easily heard @ V3 and V2. Much reduced at V1 / V0. Otherwise pretty good.
Catanets2_edit: 3.99.5 CBR modes abxable including 320k 10/10.. VBR is much better failed to abx V0
This post has been edited by shadowking: Feb 25 2013, 15:21
|Lo-Fi Version||Time is now: 19th June 2013 - 02:33|