freakngoat
Feb 25 2002, 01:31
Whatever happened to the idea of resampling to 48KHz when encoding in lame? I remember hearing it increased quality across the board at all bitrates, however there was some sort of bug in lame that produced artifacts when doing this. There was also a problem when one wished to burn to an audio CD in 44 KHz... (not a major problem at all to me).
Has this idea been abandoned, or is someone still working on this?
tangent
Feb 25 2002, 21:34
Besides LAME being untuned for 48kHz, it hasn't really been proven that resampling increases the quality. You get less bits per sample, for one thing. Even if you can increase temporal resolution, there's less bits to encode all the preecho coefficients anyway.
macdaddy
Feb 26 2002, 04:55
QUOTE
it hasn't really been proven that resampling increases the quality
That's interesting. I'm glad to hear this, because I thought I was missing something. There are some technical (and lengthy) discussions on the AVS forum that suggest the opposite...
link
link2
maciey
Feb 26 2002, 12:30
Why don't these people (at the AVS fora) do any blind testing - but just claim some things that just wouldn't pass on hydrogenaudio?
macdaddy
Feb 26 2002, 12:55
There are always different points of view, along with supporting logic, but the discussions are on the same topic as this thread, which is why I made the references...
I would imagine (theoretically) that 24/96 should sound better than 16or24/44. But I would also assume that this depends on the quality of the rest of your equipment. In my particular case, the analog stereo output equipment I own is superior to my surround receiver that works with the S/PDIF signal (and I don't think 24/96 outputs to analogOUT of the ap24/96 soundcard; only via S/PDIFout)...
I was curious about 48KHz .mpc encoding (in theory, because I don't think it exists now), but I am also sure that the developers and you guys have thought of it before, and opted to go down a different road-and I'm not even sure analogRCA connections can handle that (but I am guessing)...
The goal is the same, though: to achieve the highest quality output. I figured some of the members here would have a different take on things; I'm simply curious as to what these opinions and theories might be...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.