QUOTE(ScorLibran @ Aug 30 2003, 05:19 PM)
Ahhh...Robert Anson Heinlein...one of my very favorite authors (close second to Asimov). The book
The Puppet Masters was much better than the movie though (as is true for many book>movie transitions, including
Starship Troopers). I just started reading
Stranger in a Strange Land, and I just bought
Friday which I'll dive into next. I wish they'd make my very favorite Heinlein book into a film...
The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. Then again, maybe they shouldn't.
Sorry to get OT about books instead of movies, but when Heinlein is mentioned I have to jump in...
Don't blame you for jumping in... if anyone else had mentioned Heinlein first, I would have as well.
Yes,
The Puppet Masters novel was better than the film, but one of the reasons I rate the film so highly is that it's the
only example of Heinlein's work translated to the screen that does any semblance of justice to the original. (Sure, they had to edit a few things... after all, you want the audience to sit through the whole thing, don't you? But they did it the right way, and stayed true to Heinlein's original forcus and vision.)
Only two of his other works have been filmed (... and released; there have been numerous aborted attempts to film
Stranger in a Strange Land, but nobody really groks the way that one should be done.), and of the two
Destination Moon doesn't really count, because Heinlein conceived it as a screenplay and wrote his own novelization.
Starship Troopers was a travesty, and should never have been filmed... at least, not like it was. The animated
Roughnecks series comes much closer to the tone, theme and spirit of the novel.
All in all, I'd have to rank Heinlein ahead of Asimov as a writer... although I have the complete (yes, really) fictional works of both. The paperback versions fill two large boxes in my office - I ran out of shelf space long ago - and I'm slowly accumulating a set of their respective hardbacks.
You did get the original, uncut version of
Stranger, right? If not, PM me... I've got a few spare copies of that one lying around.
To drift back toward the original topic, I always thought
The Door Into Summer would film well, although it would have to begin as a period piece. (Or the gadgets and gizmos would have to be thoroughly re-vamped for a modern audience... but of the two options, I'd vote for the former.)
- M.
Edit: I'm feeling slow today... I forgot to close a set of italics.