Hydrogenaudio Forums > DAE

westgroveg

Jan 25 2004, 20:03

PLEXTOR_PX-W2410A_TRIAL_1

CODE

Errors total Num : 19500224
Errors (Loudness) Num : 67632 - Avg : -66.6 dB - Max : -9.3 dB
Error Muting Num : 11287 - Avg : 2.7 Samples - Max : 902 Samples
Skips Num : 209 - Avg : 32.4 Samples - Max : 1248 Samples

Total Test Result : 56.7 points (of 100.0 maximum)

PLEXTOR_PX-W2410A_TRIAL_2

CODE

Errors total Num : 21166148
Errors (Loudness) Num : 71675 - Avg : -65.8 dB - Max : -10.0 dB
Error Muting Num : 13520 - Avg : 2.5 Samples - Max : 901 Samples
Skips Num : 220 - Avg : 32.9 Samples - Max : 1332 Samples

Total Test Result : 56.4 points (of 100.0 maximum)

PLEXTOR_PX-W2410A_TRIAL_3

CODE

Errors total Num : 20886168
Errors (Loudness) Num : 71049 - Avg : -66.0 dB - Max : -10.3 dB
Error Muting Num : 13611 - Avg : 2.5 Samples - Max : 315 Samples
Skips Num : 206 - Avg : 35.0 Samples - Max : 1278 Samples

Total Test Result : 56.4 points (of 100.0 maximum)

PLEXTOR_PX-W2410A_TRIAL_4

CODE

Errors total Num : 21208476
Errors (Loudness) Num : 71701 - Avg : -65.7 dB - Max : -11.2 dB
Error Muting Num : 14024 - Avg : 2.4 Samples - Max : 381 Samples
Skips Num : 213 - Avg : 36.4 Samples - Max : 1542 Samples

Total Test Result : 56.3 points (of 100.0 maximum)

Thanks to JensRex for hosting.

sony666

Jan 25 2004, 20:22

nice graphics.. what was your point again?

westgroveg

Jan 25 2004, 20:43

QUOTE(sony666 @ Jan 26 2004, 02:22 PM)

nice graphics.. what was your point again?

The test results speak for themselves.

If you don't know what DAE Quality is then just say so.

More results,

My reference file + test CD results
-PIONEERDVD-ROMDVD-106
-PLEXTOR_PX-W2410A

Upp3rd0G's reference file + test CD results
-Plextor PX-40TS
-LiteOn LTD-163
-LiteOn LTR-40125s

Andre Wiethoff's rereference file + test CD results
-Pioneer DVD-ROM DVD-106
-Plextor CD-R PX-W2410A
-Pioneer DVD-RW A04
-Plextor CD-ROM PX-40TS (worn drive)
-Harman/Kardon HD760 (standalone)
Can all be found here

Pio's rereference file + test CD results
Memorex DVD Maxx 1648
Sony DDU1621 DVD ROM
Yamaha CRW3200EWK
Teac CD 540E (failed test)
Can all be found here

mat128

Jan 25 2004, 21:02

How do you do such nice diagrams for your results? and the results itself?

Thank you.
Mat

JoshuaL

Jan 25 2004, 23:47

Out of curiosity, are those good or bad results for the Plextor drive? (They seem to be different from Andre Weithoff's results.) I own this drive and use it for all extraction using EAC with C2 correction enabled.

westgroveg

Jan 26 2004, 00:35

QUOTE(JoshuaL @ Jan 26 2004, 05:47 PM)

Out of curiosity, are those good or bad results for the Plextor drive? (They seem to be different from Andre Weithoff's results.) I own this drive and use it for all extraction using EAC with C2 correction enabled.

Keep in mind the we have different reference files & test CD's so results may vary. With that said I personally think the results I got are rather low & I don't think they coincide with Andre's test results for this drive, I know JeanLuc has access to the same drive & has made a test CD so he may be willing to provide results for this drive.

The firmware revision could also be the cause of the differences, I had firmware 1.04 flashed on my drive.

ssjkakaroto

Jan 26 2004, 03:42

i just gave a quick read on the page you mentioned and this test show how good error correction of the drive itself is right? but does it make any difference when you're ripping non-corrupted cds?

tia

westgroveg

Jan 26 2004, 04:15

QUOTE(ssjkakaroto @ Jan 26 2004, 09:42 PM)

i just gave a quick read on the page you mentioned and this test show how good error correction of the drive itself is right? but does it make any difference when you're ripping non-corrupted cds?

tia

The better the drive performs the less probability of errors just as with EAC's secure mode & a clean CD does the same.