QUOTE
I want to rip my music from the CD's bit for bit
Gap detection is not necessary for bit-exact copy's, if you want each track to be bit-exact & keep gap info you can, detect gaps, tick
leave out gaps & create a CUE sheet (with left out gaps) which will store the gap info.
Ideally gap info would be stored in tags, the decoder/player would need to be aware & this way you could select to playback with or without gaps.
Also keep in mind that EAC's gap detection accuracy is questionable, your best shot at getting accurate gaps is method A, secure. Contrary to what Andre has said & has been written in a popular EAC guide, I can tell you gap detection methods do vary in accuracy & A was the most precise in all 5 drives I have tested.
I like the idea of the accurate rip database but I predict it will be not very useful because,
1. Lack of software support, verifiable albums will continue because,
2. Disc must be flawless (very rare) or extraction software must have accurate error recovery (also very rare)
3. Drives must overread into the corresponding offset which is very rare.