QUOTE(Digisurfer @ Sep 15 2004, 01:02 AM)
I tried allofmp3 once to see what the fuss was about. Had no problem using a Mastercard. Didn't care for it much though, as quality was too questionable in my opinion. Most material said (upon close inspection in the encoding window) that the source was alt-preset standart, not 384k freeformat as is commonly claimed around the net. What can one expect for 1 cent per song though, right? I figured for that you might as well not pay anything and just use P2P if you're so inclined (probably about just as legal as allofmp3 too). You also don't really know if you can trust the source format in the case of lossless either. It could have easily been lossy originally, you just don't know. And for the cost of downloading lossless material in a lossless format (2 cents per song, it adds up quick with large files) I might as well just buy the CD and do the work myself. Anyways, doing it myself I'm assured it's been done right with no errors (which is what I do 99.99% of the time now).
Edit: Minor fixes, additions, and some sentence restructuring to avoid confusion.
Actually after reading through some allofmp3 related posts, it seemed that the freeformat coding parameters they use are not optimal at least according to some HA residents. Besides very few players play it. So alt-preset standard would make me happier because you do not need to transcode and less can go wrong with alt-preset standard.
P2P is not good. I never tried that, so I might be wrong, but I do not want to offer my collection on line, so IMHO I cannot download either then. Even if technically possible it is not fair. Secondly, and I might be wrong again, I am not after mainstream stuff, so tracking down what I want is difficult. They have quite a few, which is interesting.
On the other hand I agree that CD s are the best. In fact that is my final goal because quality is important. The problem is that every online shop I know allows you to review the 1st approx 30 sec of the songs. 90% of the cases nothing happens there and it is difficult to decide. But the price is so good that I can download tracks dirt cheap using a low bitrate and if I like the album, I will buy it.