I don't have a whole lot of time right now to reply to all of that (I ought to have been in bed an hour ago). But I will say that, if I had to do the polarity test again, except with 1-minute tracks to compare blindly, I believe I would have absolutely failed. I had to change tracks much, much faster than that to get any sort of consistency.
By switching rapidly any chance you might be detecting some kind of interaction acoustically between the selections?
