Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What Vorbis version is the best?
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Lossy Audio Compression > Ogg Vorbis > Ogg Vorbis - General
Totuma
Hi for all wink.gif

I need a little help please... I am very confused, because the many versions of vorbis... I don't know what is the better option..

I read many topics in HA and other web sites refering to the top quality of many of the new versions of Vorbis encoders...

aoTuV b2 is one with many good references; 1.1RC1 and megamix2 too...

What is the best option? crying.gif

Please many thanks for any feedback smile.gif
Triza
Oh Boy! Why do you think we have

"Recommended Encoder Versions and Settings"

thread? Go and find it.

Triza

PS: I hope you do not expect us to create a discussion about this every time a new member joins in.
QuantumKnot
QUOTE(Totuma @ Nov 14 2004, 06:02 AM)
Hi for all  wink.gif

I need a little help please... I am very confused, because the many versions of vorbis... I don't know what is the better option..

I read many topics in HA and other web sites refering to the top quality of many of the new versions of Vorbis encoders...

aoTuV b2 is one with many good references; 1.1RC1 and megamix2 too...

What is the best option?  crying.gif

Please many thanks for any feedback  smile.gif
*


At the moment, Vorbis 1.1 is the recommended encoder. It is basically aoTuV b2 with a few bugfixes. It is also the most flexible since you can tweak it further but you shouldn't need to worry about that.
Totuma
QUOTE(QuantumKnot @ Nov 13 2004, 04:48 PM)
At the moment, Vorbis 1.1 is the recommended encoder. It is basically aoTuV b2 with a few bugfixes. It is also the most flexible since you can tweak it further but you shouldn't need to worry about that.
*


Many Thanks QuantumKnot for your fast and precise reply smile.gif happy.gif
Totuma
QUOTE(Triza @ Nov 13 2004, 01:05 PM)
Oh Boy! Why do you think we have

"Recommended Encoder Versions and Settings"

thread? Go and find it.

Triza

PS: I hope you do not expect us to create a discussion about this every time a new member joins in.
*


Triza: My honest opinion for your "cool" mad.gif reply is:
sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif sick.gif
Benjamin Lebsanft
just take your time to search a bit next time...
v4audio
UPDATE: As of 11/21/04 Aotuv B3 has been released, this will take time to be tested so that it can become the new standard. But it is of course INTENDED to be an improvement over vorbis 1.1 and not just B2...

Changelog is as follows:

QUOTE
@<<Since beta2 was adopted as official 1.1, beta3 uses 1.1 as a base. >>
  # bitrate management mode operates normally now. It not only became new, it offers new rate control. (changed part of Vorbis 1.1 by Monty)  However, it can't be used in this encoder.
@# Pre-echo was decreased in the mode of q0-q10.
  # Since some codes of beta2 were not working normally, correction and re-tuning were carried out.
@# In the mode below q3, the problem to which a part of sound becomes unstable is improved. (e.g. piano/strings)
@# Distortion resulting from channel coupling was reduced. (e.g. brass/drumus/guitar)
@# The q-2 new mode.
Totuma
QUOTE(v4audio @ Nov 19 2004, 03:11 PM)
UPDATE: As of 11/21/04 Aotuv B3 has been released, this will take time to be tested so that it can become the new standard.  But it is of course INTENDED to be an improvement over vorbis 1.1 and not just B2...

Changelog is as follows:

QUOTE
@<<Since beta2 was adopted as official 1.1, beta3 uses 1.1 as a base. >>
# bitrate management mode operates normally now. It not only became new, it offers new rate control. (changed part of Vorbis 1.1 by Monty) However, it can't be used in this encoder.
@# Pre-echo was decreased in the mode of q0-q10.
# Since some codes of beta2 were not working normally, correction and re-tuning were carried out.
@# In the mode below q3, the problem to which a part of sound becomes unstable is improved. (e.g. piano/strings)
@# Distortion resulting from channel coupling was reduced. (e.g. brass/drumus/guitar)
@# The q-2 new mode.

*


laugh.gif Many Thanks !!! I visited the Aoyumi Web site... It is very good news... smile.gif
I will test this version aoTuv b3 today...
krazy
never mind wink.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.