Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Can The Nec 3520a Copy Audio Bit For Bit Perfect?
Hydrogenaudio Forums > CD-R and Audio Hardware > CD Hardware/Software
Sgt_Strider
According to accuraterip.com, the drive is listed and the offset is also listed so I'm assuming it has the ability to copy a bit for bit audio from a audio cd right?
westgroveg
Only if it can over-read up to the corresponding offset value, this is the only real requirement for bit-exact copies from a drive.
DARcode
QUOTE(westgroveg @ Feb 3 2005, 11:06 AM)
Only if it can over-read up to the corresponding offset value, this is the only real requirement for bit-exact copies from a drive.
*


Pardon my amateursih question, but how do you test that (ability to over-read to the offset value)? Thanks.
westgroveg
QUOTE(DARcode @ Feb 3 2005, 09:14 PM)
QUOTE(westgroveg @ Feb 3 2005, 11:06 AM)
Only if it can over-read up to the corresponding offset value, this is the only real requirement for bit-exact copies from a drive.
*


Pardon my amateursih question, but how do you test that (ability to over-read to the offset value)? Thanks.
*


Find a CD in EAC's Reference CDs List, put it the drive, then press the "Detect read sample offset correction..." button. The dialog box will tell you your drives offset value & if it can overread lead I/O.
Sgt_Strider
QUOTE(westgroveg @ Feb 3 2005, 09:06 AM)
Only if it can over-read up to the corresponding offset value, this is the only real requirement for bit-exact copies from a drive.
*



I don't have the drive yet so I can't really test it out. How do I check from the reviews to see if this device is indeed capable of doing that? I really want to buy this burner, but not having the ability to copy bit perfect CD's will push me away.
precisionist
Could you please specify the burner model ?
In any case, the offset issue westgroveg mentioned only affects either the first or the last track of audio CDs (depends on the drive's offset); all other tracks will be copied bit-truely.
Sgt_Strider
QUOTE(precisionist @ Feb 4 2005, 02:39 PM)
Could you please specify the burner model ?
In any case, the offset issue westgroveg mentioned only affects either the first or the last track of audio CDs (depends on the drive's offset); all other tracks will be copied bit-truely.
*



Dude, I already listed the model # in the title and in the first post. It is the NEC 3520A. I want to use accuraterip to ensure a successful copy. Is this possible with the DVD burner?
JeanLuc
QUOTE(Sgt_Strider @ Feb 4 2005, 09:28 PM)

Dude, I already listed the model # in the title and in the first post. It is the NEC 3520A. I want to use accuraterip to ensure a successful copy. Is this possible with the DVD burner?
*



Sure ... because your drive supports "Accurate Streaming" ... it does not overread I/O but since the I/O areas do consist of silence in most cases anyway, you will hardly ever take notice of the lack of this feature (especially since the read offset for the NEC drives is low).

The only drawback is this burner's rather low error correction capability (see the review at CDR-Info on that topic) which might be a problem if you run into damaged CD's ...
Sgt_Strider
Do you happen to know if the Plextor 716-SA will be any better in the bit for bit coping department?
AtaqueEG
QUOTE(JeanLuc @ Feb 4 2005, 04:08 PM)
The only drawback is this burner's rather low error correction capability (see the review at CDR-Info on that topic) which might be a problem if you run into damaged CD's ...
*



What would a non-Plextor drive with good error correction would be?

I am much interested.

I have a Lite-On 832S, which, according to my rather limited tests, has very good correction capabilities.
There's only one factory-defective non-copy-protected CD that it cannot rip (you know, one of those scratch-free CDs, that anyway have some tracks that skip)

I am looking to buy another drive soon (but a DVD burner, and Plextor drives have been dissapointing lately)
Sgt_Strider
QUOTE(AtaqueEG @ Feb 6 2005, 05:43 AM)
QUOTE(JeanLuc @ Feb 4 2005, 04:08 PM)
The only drawback is this burner's rather low error correction capability (see the review at CDR-Info on that topic) which might be a problem if you run into damaged CD's ...
*



What would a non-Plextor drive with good error correction would be?

I am much interested.

I have a Lite-On 832S, which, according to my rather limited tests, has very good correction capabilities.
There's only one factory-defective non-copy-protected CD that it cannot rip (you know, one of those scratch-free CDs, that anyway have some tracks that skip)

I am looking to buy another drive soon (but a DVD burner, and Plextor drives have been dissapointing lately)
*



How have Plextor drives been disappointing?
JeanLuc
QUOTE(AtaqueEG @ Feb 6 2005, 05:43 AM)
I am looking to buy another drive soon (but a DVD burner, and Plextor drives have been dissapointing lately)
*



The PX-708A (which is outdated and discontinued) scored the highest perecentage ever at the CDR-Info error correction test ... and the 716A seems to be a good choice, too.

The LG GSA-4163B looks promising as well ...
westgroveg
QUOTE(JeanLuc @ Feb 6 2005, 08:52 PM)
QUOTE(AtaqueEG @ Feb 6 2005, 05:43 AM)
I am looking to buy another drive soon (but a DVD burner, and Plextor drives have been dissapointing lately)
*



The PX-708A (which is outdated and discontinued) scored the highest perecentage ever at the CDR-Info error correction test ... and the 716A seems to be a good choice, too.
*


Put it together with PlexTools DAE & you will have unbeatable error correction & recovery
evereux
[off-topic]
I have the NEC ND-1300A and the Plextor PX-708A. I was given a data disc last week by a friend that was said to be unreadable (there was an obvious radial scratch right through the metallic layer). The NEC ND-1300A couldn't read anything from this disc, even the TOC. The Plextor managed to retrieve all but 5 images from a total of 30, plus an application on that disc.

This Plextor plus Plextools has been excellent for me.
[/off-topic]
precisionist
QUOTE(Sgt_Strider @ Feb 4 2005, 10:28 PM)
Dude, I already listed the model # in the title and in the first post. It is the NEC 3520A.
*


Eyes get tired when sitting at the PC so long... lalala.gif wacko.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.