waouw I like this player a LOT ...
I am a 5 years of winamp (+album list plugin) user spending the last year looking toward foobar to know if I should use it as default or not (don't like its look & feel ... & mainly its basic freeware only license) ... I tryed swichwing several time but always get back to my good'old winamp, using foobar as a winamp extension, not really a core player remplacement...
in the end the not open source license has driven me away from foobar from start as I didn't wanted a player that could potentially follow the same mistake as winamp ... foobar is an increadibly good player ... but it's not for me simply ...
I think I have tryed pretty much every players on earth this last year seaching for a successor to winamp ... I tryed zinf, coolplayer, delpamph, quintessential player, core player, xmplay, vuplayer, wxmusik & many many others ... I was almost falling to the conclusion that it was time to switch to linux xmms/rythmbox for me (I haven't tryed amarok yet)
for the first time I think I MAY have found it ...
unlike foobar it's not a complicated player so it has a big potential for the mass end users
unlike winamp & foobar it's not proprietary so it has a big potential for core & plugin third party development
I just tortured my fresh musikCube for a couple of hours, so here is my feeling about it :
- BUG "start to tray with windows" don't work for me, whatever I do, it just don't save (WinXP SP2) I like winamp tray agent, I need it for musikCube
- I unchecked crossfading & ballon tip ... I didn't saw any tips but I heard the tip noise when double clicking on a song ... it was annoying as hell during the 5 first minutes ... so crossfade+tip noise at same time ... ugh ... I had the feeling my musikcube was destroying my musik first ;( ... this default isn't a very good idea ...
- plz use vorbis Q5 & flac C5 as default in the ripper ... the more the your experience with these codecs will grow the more you will find Q6 & C8 useless (small swaste of space for the first, big waste of time for the second when transcoding ... even if encoding is faster than ripping for ya, when you will transcode a lot of ape to flac you'll use C5 as you will soon be bored of waiting with C8) I don't care about flac C5 as it can be argueed but I care for vorbis Q5 as I know for sure Q5 is ten time more popular then Q6 even if all vorbis newbie using APS with lame starts using vorbis Q6 ... it's a newbie mistake plz don't feed them)
- plz display flac & vorbis vendor string in propriety ... plz separate & display vorbis nominal/average/max-min bitrate like winamp does
- plz add artwork JPG-PNG display support (I use PNG front 1417x1417px ~3mo) targetting "front" in image filename in the folder currently played
- plz add "find file on disk" like the winamp plug ...
- ability to drag down the middle bar between artist/album top & songs bottom
- plz go deep in this way: Itunes GUI but with separate tunable elements + Winamp Plugins + Free Software ... Free Software & modularity will bring you plugin coders ... with time plugins coders will code almost every missing foobar like features if the core soft worth it as a base ...
don't understimate plugins & skins ... skins may be completly useless ... in the end it's winamp modularity & highly tunable level (plugin+skins) that made its success ...
there must be a way to simply tune its graphical aspect ... following the core skin is nice ... but many newbie don't even know you can change all windows skins aspect by changing the default XP style ... even without skins it must be possible to change the colors & layout for real noobs ...
plz use in plugins even for core codecs something like incubevorbis.dll incubeflac.dll incubemp3.dll ... this system is very popular ...
---
I don't care about dead shn/mpc support, I care about mp4/wavpack/monkey audio support
I don't care about replaygain, cue+single album rip support
(I don't trust in cue as playlist remplacement for lossless, I trust in splitted files
I don't trust in the usefullness of replaygain at all ... it's a mpc freak thing for me ...)
for me musikCube must be state of the art for Xiph codecs, specially Ogg/Flac ...
even if I think mp4/monkey support would be great for others in the end I don't care I will not use these codec anyway ... due to patents & non-OSI license ... monkey support is important for reading tags before flac transcoding ... not for playback ...
monkey/wavpack support would be nicer than mp4 support for me
people that care about musikcube over winamp/foobar care for license ...
the only thing musikcube brings is its license & a very good Xiph-tunes alternative ...
you want mp4, use itunes it's the original ... then go ask itunes dev for xiph support ... instead of asking musikCube to support mp4 ...
you want mpc/replaygain/cue support, use foobar it's the original/best ... then go ask foobar dev for GNU ... instead of asking musikCube for mpc/replaygain/cue support ...
but if you simply want a free winamp for your free codecs ... then maybe musikcube will do the job ... it's boring to see people asking features specific to a single player ...
mp4-proprietary soft users are funny ... they use patented or rare closed solutions ...
& then they cry for free software dev to support their bad choice, to correct their mistakes ... grow old you're responsible of your choices ...
"hey MrQM, musikCube, Audacity plz oh plz support mp4"... I am bored of hearing that ... plz don't support mp4 ... or ask mpeg/nero/apple money for it ... (ok, ok that's zealotry ... but there is some truth & logic in it ...)
just open your eyes, just test other audio players ... 90% of players around don't support mp4 (itunes) or replaygain/cue/masstagging/transcoding (foobar) ...
... if you are too lazy to use an external masstagger/transcoder ... too simple-minded to use free codecs ... it's not musikCube's dev fault ... there is several good external option to do these jobs ...
I don't say musikCube shouldn't do all this ... the more an audio player got features the better it is ... but exotic/patented/useless features shouldn't be priority ...
musikCube's job is to freely playback my free musik & it does it well for a newcomer ...
depending on its future improvements I think I will switch to musikCube over winamp at some point in its dev ... congratulations ...
I recall several months ago I told the idea here that Xiph was afterall a part of Gnome & should team with Rythmbox & port "this player with its embeded codecs" into windows to fight mp4/itunes ... some users here told me it was stupid ... maybe it was not, cauz with musikCube/musikBox ... that's almost what you created .... the xIphTunes ... thks

it was just my first impressions brainstorming ... more feedback to come as bug/missing features arise ... sorry if it was a bit messy & sometimes anti-patents pro-gnu ...