Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Repeated Encoding and Decoding
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Hydrogenaudio Forum > General Audio
myname
Hi,

Will a .wav file lose its quality, when it is frequently encoded and decoded from one format to another ?
smile.gif
guruboolez
yes. Each encoding [EDIT: each lossy encoding] adds quantization noise, and therefore lowers the overall, objective and sometimes subjective quality.
robert
as everytime, it depends: if you encode lossless ie with flac, then no
myname
Thanks a lot, guruboolez, robert !! smile.gif
Leo 69
To my mind encoding from wav to, for example, mp3, then decompressing mp3 back to wav and then
again encoding into mp3 (and again, and again) will face the mp3's flaws and they will be more and more evident to the listener with each reencoding. Maybe this will help LAME developers to find and fix some weaknesses at an "early stage", so to say, won't it ?
Jebus
QUOTE (Leo 69 @ Mar 10 2005, 10:11 AM)
To my mind encoding from wav to, for example, mp3, then decompressing mp3 back to wav and then
again encoding into mp3 (and again, and again) will face the mp3's flaws and they will be more and more evident to the listener with each reencoding. Maybe this will help LAME developers to find and fix some weaknesses at an "early stage", so to say, won't it ?
*


Its not that flaws multiply, rather the "desired" quantization noise multiplies. MP3 is SUPPOSED to insert noise into a recording, so this wouldn't help LAME developers insert less, or anything like that.
e268
QUOTE (robert @ Mar 9 2005, 04:14 PM)
as everytime, it depends: if you encode lossless ie with flac, then no
*


What about compressed flac? Will successive decompressing and re-compressing flac files change the quality?
phong
Flac is lossless, hence zero loss. You can encode and decode flac as many times as you want, and there will be zero loss in quality.
unfortunateson
QUOTE
What about compressed flac? Will successive decompressing and re-compressing flac files change the quality?

it seems you believe that compression = loss of quality. That is not the case, it depends on the codec used. FLAC compression still produces a lossless file, whereas MP3 compression produces a lossy file.

Edit: Added Quote.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.