Only negative comments
I think the design is pretty cool. Yes, a radiator works better, but this looks IMO cooler.
He uses water, tap water has usualy a lower temperature then ambient air.
If you use ice the water temperature stays cool. This is obvious better then just leaving the fridgedoor open because:
1) everything would spoil
2) a frdige has a relative low cooling capacity
3) as long as you dont have +100% efficiency, you are just warming up the room
Using ice out of the freezer works better because the freezer can take all night to freeze it, so the ice is in fact a cooling battery

. If you need a constant supply of ice this argument doesnt count obviously.
I think cool tap water has a higher cooling capacity anyway (compared to a fridge), so the ice doesnt even matter that much.
Doesnt an airco use a lot of electricity. It differs from country to country, but isnt the cost of electricity more expensive on the long run then the price of the airco itself?
If its really warm, the garden might also benefit from the water which is useed to cool. So you can turn of the garden sprinkler.
All in all i find it a pretty creative solution