Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Nero HE-AAC v2, is it better then AACPlus v2?
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Lossy Audio Compression > AAC > AAC - Tech
Pages: 1, 2
Kostarum Rex Persia
I assume that new Nero 7 Premium edition include brand new Nero HE-AAC v2 audio codec,am I right. Is v2 of HE-AAC better then Coding technologies AACPlus v1 and v2 AAC, or not.

Garf
The new Nero HE-AACv2 encoder will be in the web release.

Nero Digital and aacPlusv2 are both implementations of the same HE-AACv2 standard.

Since the new Nero encoder is not public yet, nobody will be able to answer your question.
Kostarum Rex Persia
QUOTE(Garf @ Oct 13 2005, 07:58 PM)
Since the new Nero encoder is not public yet, nobody will be able to answer your question.
*



Ok,but can you promise me an answer on my question when web release of Nero 7 came out.Thanks.
yourtallness
QUOTE(Kostarum Rex Persia @ Oct 13 2005, 04:04 PM)
QUOTE(Garf @ Oct 13 2005, 07:58 PM)
Since the new Nero encoder is not public yet, nobody will be able to answer your question.
*



Ok,but can you promise me an answer on my question when web release of Nero 7 came out.Thanks.
*



You can be more than sure that the two encoders will be thoroughly compared
once the new Nero encoder becomes widely available.

No need for anyone to promise it.
yulyo!
Dear Graf, do you have any ideea whan n7 will be released?
AndyMutz
QUOTE(yulyo! @ Oct 14 2005, 07:32 PM)
Dear Graf, do you have any ideea whan  n7 will be released?
*



the nero homepage states, that nero 7 will be available for online purchase on october the 26th. i assume it will then be possible to download the web release.

http://www.nero.com/nero7/eng/index.html

-andy-
dtiernan
QUOTE(yourtallness @ Oct 14 2005, 12:41 AM)
QUOTE(Kostarum Rex Persia @ Oct 13 2005, 04:04 PM)
QUOTE(Garf @ Oct 13 2005, 07:58 PM)
Since the new Nero encoder is not public yet, nobody will be able to answer your question.
*



Ok,but can you promise me an answer on my question when web release of Nero 7 came out.Thanks.
*



You can be more than sure that the two encoders will be thoroughly compared
once the new Nero encoder becomes widely available.

No need for anyone to promise it.
*




Is the Nero encoder (I have it) compatible with the industry standard?
Garf
QUOTE(dtiernan @ Oct 26 2005, 03:31 AM)
Is the Nero encoder (I have it) compatible with the industry standard?
*



You do not have the HE-AACv2 encoder. You can have the HE-AACv1 encoder though, that one has been available for a while.

All Nero products are fully compatible with the MPEG standards.
dimzon
Nero 7 is OUT!

user posted image
user posted image
dimzon
user posted image
Leo 69
QUOTE
Nero HE-AAC v2, is it better then AACPlus v2?


Yes it is, no doubt now. Garf was right about very listenable quality @ 32 and 48 kbps smile.gif
rjamorim
QUOTE(Leo 69 @ Nov 1 2005, 02:07 PM)
QUOTE
Nero HE-AAC v2, is it better then AACPlus v2?


Yes it is, no doubt now. Garf was right about very listenable quality @ 32 and 48 kbps smile.gif
*



Have you done a blind listening test comparing it to Winamp 5.1 encoder?
Leo 69
No I haven't, ain't got time at the moment.. But I know how my favourite songs sounded before with Winamp AAC encoder and now, they sound different with Nero encoder..they sound definitely better at the same bitrate. I am 99% sure about that
IgorC
Same for me. Difference between all HE-AAC2 isnīt so big. but Nero is best for me. Top bitrate for PS is aprox 51 kbit/s.
Garf
Well, let's not get into a massive TOS8 violation spree here.

But it would of course be appreciated if someone would set up a proper listening test [1], so we can settle the matter.

[1] Proper meaning: performed by more than 1 person.
dimzon
WARNING

Seems like there are wrong channel mapping in 5.1 encoding using BeSweet! (There are significant audio fluctuations). Can anybody check it too?

There are 3 variants:
  1. Wait until Nero fix the problem
  2. OR Ask DSPGuru to change channel order for bsn
  3. OR Write tiny wrapper around original bsn.dll and change channel mapping in it (i can write such wrapper for -dimzon switch but i need information which channel mapping reqied for Nero7)
umbi
Hi!
I got my long-awaited brand new Nero 7.0.1.2.Now I got some questions:

1)For Dimzon:what's the name of the utility you're using (file info) and where I can download it?
2)Converting to aac 48 kb/s I don't see any option for setting parametric stereo.Where is it?
3)Getting the info file (using winamp) about a aac track converted by nero,the profile is always LC instead of HE (effectivly used).Why?
Garf
QUOTE(umbi @ Nov 2 2005, 02:16 PM)
Hi!
I got my long-awaited brand new Nero 7.0.1.2.Now I got some questions:

1)For Dimzon:what's the name of the utility you're using (file info) and where I can download it?


a recent foobar2000 0.9 beta

QUOTE
2)Converting to aac 48 kb/s I don't see any option for setting parametric stereo.Where is it?


It's used automagically when it's beneficial.

QUOTE
3)Getting the info file (using winamp) about a aac track converted by nero,the profile is always LC instead of HE (effectivly used).Why?
*



Because Winamp is buggy.
dimzon
QUOTE(dimzon @ Nov 1 2005, 09:57 PM)
WARNING

Seems like there are wrong channel mapping in 5.1 encoding using BeSweet! (There are significant audio fluctuations). Can anybody check it too?

There are 3 variants:

  1. Wait until Nero fix the problem
  2. OR Ask DSPGuru to change channel order for bsn
  3. OR Write tiny wrapper around original bsn.dll and change channel mapping in it (i can write such wrapper for -dimzon switch but i need information which channel mapping reqied for Nero7)

*


Workaround
dimzon
Garf
Plesae can You tell us whats exatly new in new Nero encoder (new psy model, which improvements etc) ?

Does PS part works for 5.1 encoding?
Garf
QUOTE
Plesae can You tell us whats exatly new in new Nero encoder (new psy model, which improvements etc) ?


Basically everything was improved. In terms of features Parametric Stereo is new.

QUOTE
Does PS part works for 5.1 encoding?
*



Parametric Stereo is not defined for more than 2 channels. There is work in progress at MPEG to define a multichannel version (Spatial Audio). When that is finished, we will support it.
Kostarum Rex Persia
Can newest Nero AAC encoder work from some other program, etc. dBpowerAMP Music Converter, or freeware Mediacoder 0.32

dBpowerAMP Music Converter already support older version of Nero AAC encoder from year 2004.
dimzon
QUOTE(Kostarum Rex Persia @ Nov 3 2005, 08:34 PM)
Can newest Nero AAC encoder work from some other program, etc. dBpowerAMP Music Converter, or freeware Mediacoder 0.32

dBpowerAMP Music Converter already support older version of Nero AAC encoder from year 2004.
*



Yes!
Kostarum Rex Persia
Please explain? When the newest Nero AAC encoder will be adapted with newest dBpowerAMP Music Converter 11.5, on their site there is no information about that.
rudefyet
so what's the difference between the "high" and "fast" modes now?
dimzon
QUOTE(Kostarum Rex Persia @ Nov 4 2005, 03:17 AM)
Please explain? When the newest Nero AAC encoder will be adapted with newest dBpowerAMP Music Converter 11.5, on their site there is no information about that.
*


Nero7 has same API so you can still use dbPowerAmp
Ivan Dimkovic
QUOTE
so what's the difference between the "high" and "fast" modes now?


Fast mode uses simple scalefactor estimation to gain speed - high mode uses SFE + additional noise shaping processing. Also there are some differences in precision etc...
guruboolez
QUOTE(Ivan Dimkovic @ Nov 7 2005, 11:44 AM)
QUOTE
so what's the difference between the "high" and "fast" modes now?


Fast mode uses simple scalefactor estimation to gain speed - high mode uses SFE + additional noise shaping processing. Also there are some differences in precision etc...
*


The difference (quality, speed) between HIGH and FAST is now very small. Both modes react in the same way. Sometimes, I get identical results. It seems that both modes are sharing the same engine (it was very different with previous encoder). Could you confirm?
Garf
You can see high mode as fast mode + optimization process.
dimzon
Garf
Nero7 effective bitrate for HE-AAC in VBR mode is higher then Nero6. Using same sample to comress -vbr_tape i get ~32kbps @ Nero6 and ~40kbps @ Nero7. Why?

guruboolez
QUOTE(Garf @ Nov 7 2005, 01:16 PM)
You can see high mode as fast mode + optimization process.
*


It seems that the previous fast mode worked differently than the current one. The previous FAST encoder was used to bloat the bitrate with some stuff (highly tonal samples, harpsichord...) and to keep a great quality with these samples; current encoder has now a much lower bitrate and (much) poorer quality (edit: with these samples, and with both HIGH and FAST modes). crying.gif
Enig123
Nero team will not change anything because of one person's listening test result. But I'd suggest making the bitrate bloat / bitrate uncertainty an adjustable parameter that can be altered by the user.
Ivan Dimkovic
Actually this will be changed, but in a better way.

QUOTE
Nero7 effective bitrate for HE-AAC in VBR mode is higher then Nero6. Using same sample to comress -vbr_tape i get ~32kbps @ Nero6 and ~40kbps @ Nero7. Why?


N7 vbr_tape is using Parametric Stereo core - and a different internal VBR preset.
dimzon
QUOTE(Ivan Dimkovic @ Nov 7 2005, 05:27 PM)
Actually this will be changed, but in a better way.

QUOTE
Nero7 effective bitrate for HE-AAC in VBR mode is higher then Nero6. Using same sample to comress -vbr_tape i get ~32kbps @ Nero6 and ~40kbps @ Nero7. Why?


N7 vbr_tape is using Parametric Stereo core - and a different internal VBR preset.
*



there are same effect for vbr_streaming and vbr_normal too
Ivan Dimkovic
Due to different VBR engine bitrates could be different - some people, i.e. complain about smaller avg. bit rate for the normal preset.

dimzon
QUOTE(Ivan Dimkovic @ Nov 7 2005, 06:32 PM)
Due to different VBR engine bitrates could be different - some people, i.e. complain about smaller avg. bit rate for the normal preset.
*


for LC avg bitrate is smaller but for SBR avg bitrate is always bigger sad.gif

And one more question - why your encoder support SBR encoding @ bitrate bigger then 40kbps per channel? LC encoder sound's MUCH better or such bitrates...
Kostarum Rex Persia
What about LC-AAC mode in newest Nero 7 AAC encoder? What is improved here? I mean on 128 kbps, 192 kbps and 256 kbps bitrates.
Garf
QUOTE(dimzon @ Nov 7 2005, 04:36 PM)
QUOTE(Ivan Dimkovic @ Nov 7 2005, 06:32 PM)
Due to different VBR engine bitrates could be different - some people, i.e. complain about smaller avg. bit rate for the normal preset.
*


for LC avg bitrate is smaller but for SBR avg bitrate is always bigger sad.gif

And one more question - why your encoder support SBR encoding @ bitrate bigger then 40kbps per channel? LC encoder sound's MUCH better or such bitrates...
*



HE-AAC is not defaulted for those bitrates, is it?
Garf
QUOTE(Kostarum Rex Persia @ Nov 7 2005, 05:14 PM)
What about LC-AAC mode in newest Nero 7 AAC encoder? What is improved here? I mean on 128 kbps, 192 kbps and 256 kbps bitrates.
*



Quality is better. ("What else did you expect?")
Garf
QUOTE(Enig123 @ Nov 7 2005, 03:21 PM)
Nero team will not change anything because of one person's listening test result.
*



That sums it up pretty well. I would much prefer a proper test, as I already said. We will not revise the tuning based on one persons result, and I hope that other people don't base their decisions on just that, either. We did internal tests and decided that the current settings seem to be best, and are an improvement over the old encoder, fast or high mode.
dimzon
Garf
Does You perform internal listening tests during encoder developmen/tuningt? Can You public results?
Thanx!
Garf
QUOTE(dimzon @ Nov 7 2005, 07:21 PM)
Garf
Does You perform internal listening tests during encoder developmen/tuningt?


Yes, of course...

QUOTE
Can You public results?
Thanx!
*



I don't want to do that. (Well, the encoder is public, that's one result of those tests!)
Kostarum Rex Persia
One more thing. Garf, you said that new AAC encoder can be used in DbPowerAmp 11.5.With that program, I encode WAV files into AAC.

Question is: If I install Nero 7.0.1.2 on my computer, will DbPowerAmp 11.5 automaticly start to encode in newest AAC encoder.

P.S. I installed from their site plug-in who enables Nero AAC support.
Leo 69
QUOTE(Kostarum Rex Persia @ Nov 7 2005, 01:17 PM)
One more thing. Garf, you said that new AAC encoder can be used in DbPowerAmp 11.5.With that program, I encode WAV files into AAC.

Question is: If I install Nero 7.0.1.2 on my computer, will DbPowerAmp 11.5 automaticly start to encode in newest AAC encoder.

P.S. I installed from their site plug-in who enables Nero AAC support.
*



Yes it is working alright, I've been using the same for two days already..
extesy
QUOTE(Ivan Dimkovic @ Nov 7 2005, 05:27 PM)
N7 vbr_tape is using Parametric Stereo core - and a different internal VBR preset.

And what N7 presets other than vbr_tape does use PS core by default?
kurtnoise
cbr 24 kbps
cbr 32 kbps
cbr 48 kbps
vbr_tape
vbr_radio
IgorC
There is new version of CD-DA extractor http://www.poikosoft.com/
It has a fresh HE-AAC2 from Codingtechnologies.
elmar3rd
QUOTE(IgorC @ Dec 3 2005, 02:52 PM)
There is new version of CD-DA extractor http://www.poikosoft.com/
It has a fresh HE-AAC2 from  Codingtechnologies.
*


You can get aacPlus v2 CD-extraction for free with winamp and aacPlus v2-transcoding with the transcoder-plugin.

You should know of http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index....68
Daijoubu
Transcoder never worked for me and many other...
Anyhow, I'm using that ghetto aacplusenc.exe command line tool tongue.gif
spoon
QUOTE(dimzon @ Nov 7 2005, 10:22 AM)
QUOTE(Kostarum Rex Persia @ Nov 4 2005, 03:17 AM)
Please explain? When the newest Nero AAC encoder will be adapted with newest dBpowerAMP Music Converter 11.5, on their site there is no information about that.
*


Nero7 has same API so you can still use dbPowerAmp
*



Something has changed in Nero 7, if used from an external program it times out after 30 or so encodes even though it is the full version.

It is on our fix list, could be something as simple as the nero stuff needing the active folder set to \nero\, could be anything.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.