If you are trying to do blind AB testing, you may have a more difficulty with the soundcard to amplifier/transducer part.
Feeding the soundcards can be done with two copies of the audio file running through two different software players, each specifying a different output device. There are restrictions if desiring to use ASIO drivers. I think the OS can't have two different ones active at the same time and two different soundcards will not use the same driver.
All in all you would probably be better off convincing yourself you are happy with RightMark Audio Analyzer
http://audio.rightmark.org/index_new.shtml