Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Lame No Gap Option
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Lossy Audio Compression > MP3 > MP3 - General
Soren
Still doing some experiments to find how to encode my music, i discover the no gap option in the all2lame front end. Using the recommanded lame compile (3.90.2) with the front end, all working good, files are gapless smile.gif

But...

For some reason, tag.exe didn't want to add id3 tag and file time is messed. Winamp give me error on remaining time as well of elapsed time. Also when i look at file info box, winamp didn't calculate the average bitrate. Since i'm ripping for my future slim X, i don`t want files to have time messed.

What i'm doing wrong ?

Soren

Edit : encoding options was --alt-preset extreme
M
Hmm... I use a RioVolt SP-250 (the Slim-X's little brother), but the firmware is very closely related for the two. For general MP3 encoding I use the same compile of LAME, with the All2Lame frontend as well, but after much testing I decided to stick with CBR encoding rather than VBR for this device; also, I'm using ID3v2 tags (which TAG doesn't write). My reasons have some thought behind them, although doubtless many here would tell me I'm doing it all wrong. laugh.gif With tags at the beginning of each track the player doesn't have to seek to the end of a long file before telling me what's playing, and with ID3v2 any audio encoded as VBR sometimes acts "wonky." So my current LAME encoding options are "--alt-preset cbr 192" with "--nogap" turned on via All2Lame, following which I use an ID3v2-capable tagger to write the tags by hand. Not the most elegant solution, but it works.

However, this still won't result in "gapless" audio on your Slim-X! Unfortunately, because of the way the iRiver firmware handles MP3 audio there will always be a small gap between MP3 tracks, similar to what occurs in Winamp if you aren't using a gapless-output plugin. For the life of me, I can't understand why they haven't taken a page from CoolPlayer's book of tricks - integrated gapless output is the way to go. But so far, the only media an iRiver CD-based player will play in a truly gapless fashion are Redbook (audio) CDs... and that was only added in the most recent firmware upgrades.

If you want gapless playback of compressed audio on an iRiver device, your best bet may be to encode your audio in an inherently gapless format (such as OGG or MPC - although iRiver has only promised support for OGG at this point) and pray that their firmware implementation allows for gapless playback. Sorry I couldn't offer any more help.

- M.
Jan S.
The --nogap switch was never finished and is very experimental and unfinished.
To add it to a frontend is IMO very irresponsible.


edit:
From LAME change log
QUOTE
LAME 3.89beta   July 5 2001
# Mark Taylor: preliminary --nogap support

QUOTE
LAME 3.90    December 21 2001
# Mark Taylor:  More work on --nogap


It is not mentioned further and from an old discussion on www.audiofora.com it was stated that no developer have wanted to develop this switch and that it has nasty known bugs.
trinix
QUOTE(Soren @ Nov 12 2002, 09:33 PM)
Still doing some experiments to find how to encode my music, i discover the no gap option in the all2lame front end.  Using the recommanded lame compile (3.90.2) with the front end, all working good, files are gapless  smile.gif ...

Hi,

I tried the Gapless feature in All2LAME but it didn't work.
I ripped two songs from a CD in *.wav and then I tried to encode the two files as one MP3 file without a gap. I got one MP3 file but still with the gap between the two songs.
Anybody knows what I am doing wrong? unsure.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.