Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Compress FLAC in Foobar vs Command Line
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Lossless Audio Compression > FLAC
j7n
When compressing via plain non-stdin command line interface the FLAC files come out a little smaller than by using Foobar for trancoding. Foobar has added some additional data at the beginning of the file. What is the purpose of this data? I haven't noticed that seeking would be slower without it.


Frontah:
Screenshot

Foobar v0.8.3 + FLAC v1.1.2/v1.1.3:
Screenshot
Firon
That's strange...
guruboolez
Just a guess, but... shouldn't there be 8 KB padded datas at the beginning of any flac (1.1.3) file? From what I see on the first screenshot, they're clearly missing. Did you add a commandline to disable or lower the padding size?
Firon
He said there was 20kb of junk though, and if the default is 8kb, that wouldn't account for all that data.
Egor
This is a known issue (lots of seekpoints with fb2k) and unfortunately Peter isn't going to fix it sad.gif

Topic at hydrogenaudio.org
Bug at sourceforge.net
j7n
I have set the padding to 1 kB. Thank you for the explanation, Egor.
alvaro84
You should try to convert it using a tempfile (I don't have foobar here right now, so I can't write more specific, but it can be specified in the converter profiles in foobar) - it should reduce the number of seekpoints to a normal level (works well for me).
You won't see that beatiful progress bar and speed indicator, though laugh.gif

(but I haven't tried to convert w/o tempfile since 0.9.1, it may be fixed since then blink.gif)
Mangix
QUOTE(Egor @ Dec 9 2006, 08:18) *

This is a known issue (lots of seekpoints with fb2k) and unfortunately Peter isn't going to fix it sad.gif

Topic at hydrogenaudio.org
Bug at sourceforge.net

i could be wrong, but i believe he already explained why foobar2000 does that. see here
Egor
QUOTE(Mangix @ Dec 10 2006, 01:09) *
i could be wrong, but i believe he already explained why foobar2000 does that. see here

Thanks for the link, but I would agree with ghido's RAW support proposal in the thread you mentioned.

Currently the 'invalid length' feature makes it impossible to encode large audio streams with flac.exe neither with stdin nor with temporary WAV file (as foobar2000 produces broken >2GB WAV files).
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.