Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Is it possible to convert FLAC to AAC?
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Lossless Audio Compression > Lossless / Other Codecs
TempestGarden
If so, is it advisable?

I figured since FLAC is lossless it should be okay to do so, but I am not sure.

If it is possible, can someone please suggest to me how I would go about doing so? Normally when converting to AAC I would just use iTunes, but I don't think you can do so in this case. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks.
gottkaiser
It is no problem.
My suggestion would be: http://www.bonkenc.org/.
TempestGarden
QUOTE(gottkaiser @ Feb 8 2007, 13:03) *

It is no problem.
My suggestion would be: http://www.bonkenc.org/.


Thanks for the suggestion!

Is it easy to use?
gottkaiser
Just have to choose the encoder and then the quality you want.
Than it's ready to go. :-)
TempestGarden
QUOTE(gottkaiser @ Feb 8 2007, 13:13) *

Just have to choose the encoder and then the quality you want.
Than it's ready to go. :-)


What frequency bandwidth should I use (Hz)? It's set at 16000 by default. And what is AAC object type? (LOL) Does this allow you to encode in with VBR?
gottkaiser
I'm not so sure about the encoder configuration with AAC. (normaly I use OGG)
Maybe you have a look in the Wiki. There are lot's of descriptions. Just google a bit.

Good luck! ;-)
Firon
foobar2000 + Nero Digital. -q 0.4 to get somewhere near 128kbps, VBR. May need to add -lc so it only does LC-AAC encoding.
Jebus
You can also try Omni Encoder with either the iTunes of Nero encoders. Pretty darn easy to use.
rohangc
Is there a way to convert from FLAC to protected AAC files using any of the above methods? Don't get me wrong...I do not support DRM. The problem is, I am tired of people coming up to me and asking me "Can you give me a copy of those mp3s?". I don't like it when I spend a considerable amount of money on my music CDs while people just want them (sometimes EXPECT them mad.gif ) for free from me.

With protected AAC files, I can just blame Steve Jobs for not being able to fulfill their requests wink.gif .
gonza
Well then you DO support DRM.. :-)
And, No, you can't create FairPlay protected files yourself.

My suggestion: Just be mean and say "no way Im giving you my mp3s!!!"

Gonza
Ivan Dimkovic
Just rename them to .m4p and associate your MPEG-4 player with .m4p files.

Then, when someone comes - just say "look, these are all .m4p ones - you know, protected with DRM"

smile.gif
gonza
Or.. better yet:

"Transcode" all those FLAC files to cassette tapes. Then throw away your ipod, and go back to a walkman and cassettes. Nobody is going to ask you for those !!!

And you will look so cool.

Gonza
Remedial Sound
QUOTE(TempestGarden @ Feb 8 2007, 16:16) *

What frequency bandwidth should I use (Hz)? It's set at 16000 by default. And what is AAC object type? (LOL) Does this allow you to encode in with VBR?

The free Nero commandline encoder is excellent and pretty simple - you don't need to worry about bandwidth and object types - just set the q parameter. Here's the sticky on recommended settings.

http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index....showtopic=44310

And even though Jebus is plugging his own creation tongue.gif , Omni Encoder is a great, easy-to-use GUI frontend.

QUOTE(Firon @ Feb 8 2007, 17:08) *

foobar2000 + Nero Digital. -q 0.4 to get somewhere near 128kbps, VBR. May need to add -lc so it only does LC-AAC encoding.

I'm pretty sure that -q0.4 ~128kbps will always yield LC by default. I couldn't find the discussion thread, but IIRC it was confirmed by one of the Nero devs that HE doesn't kick in until you go down to around 80 kbps (don't quote me on that exact number smile.gif , though I'm certain it's below 100 kbps)
rohangc
QUOTE(gonza @ Feb 9 2007, 07:47) *

Well then you DO support DRM.. :-)
And, No, you can't create FairPlay protected files yourself.

My suggestion: Just be mean and say "no way Im giving you my mp3s!!!"

Gonza


unsure.gif

QUOTE(Ivan Dimkovic @ Feb 9 2007, 08:00) *

Just rename them to .m4p and associate your MPEG-4 player with .m4p files.

Then, when someone comes - just say "look, these are all .m4p ones - you know, protected with DRM"

smile.gif


smile.gif

QUOTE(gonza @ Feb 9 2007, 08:22) *

Or.. better yet:

"Transcode" all those FLAC files to cassette tapes. Then throw away your ipod, and go back to a walkman and cassettes. Nobody is going to ask you for those !!!

And you will look so cool.

Gonza


biggrin.gif

Yes! That is exactly what I will do!!! Guess what? I just realized that ever since I discovered digital music, I have enjoyed my music LESS. I am always worried about which song to play next rather than actually listening to the music. I remember those wonderful days of audio cassettes...pop one in and you listen to the whole album...one song at a time... rolleyes.gif
Borisz
QUOTE(gonza @ Feb 9 2007, 14:22) *

Or.. better yet:

"Transcode" all those FLAC files to cassette tapes. Then throw away your ipod, and go back to a walkman and cassettes. Nobody is going to ask you for those !!!

And you will look so cool.

Gonza

Haha, that's the best DRM related suggestion I ever read.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.