QUOTE (tenvictor @ Feb 3 2009, 05:15)

WMA cause that's what my car supports... well, that and mp3... but WMA is smaller size so I use 128kbps.
Since you are transcoding 4000+ files and your car player supports both MP3 and WMA, I'd go with MP3 @ 128kbps.
With the high inherent ambient noise in a car, I doubt you would be able to notice any difference between MP3 and WMA @ 128kbps VBR.