Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Generic MP3GAIN/Replaygain question
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Lossy Audio Compression > MP3 > MP3 - Tech
Zaraza
Is the level of 89dB what most people really use out there?

Also, when a song is flagged as "Clip" how bad is that really? Can that be ignored (it just nicely compresses it so you can't hear it) or will actually generate an audible artifact?

I was looking for an in-depth FAQ on the usage of mp3gain (total newbie, I just used it on my first CD full of MP3s and it definitely made them easier to listen to as a whole), but before I go on and start using it across the board, I'd really like to know:

a) is 89 db the level I should always use? If yes, then why?
b) if a song on a CD is flagged as "Clip" how serious is that? Should I lower the level of the entire CD just because of that 1 MP3 (let's say 1 out of 100) or can I just safely ignore it?

Thanks in advance for clearing this up...
Snelg
QUOTE
Originally posted by Zaraza
a) is 89 db the level I should always use?


Not necessarily. That's just a fairly "safe" level at which most songs will not have any clipping (although I've found a few that do).

QUOTE
b) if a song on a CD is flagged as \"Clip\" how serious is that? Should I lower the level of the entire CD just because of that 1 MP3 (let's say 1 out of 100) or can I just safely ignore it?


The seriousness of the clipping depends on your ears. If you can't hear it (a "crackle" sound during the loud parts of the song), then no problem. If you can, you could probably just move the gain down a tiny bit for that one song. (Use the "Constant Gain" function in mp3gain).

-Glen
Zaraza
What does Constant Gain do exactly?
YinYang
QUOTE
Originally posted by Zaraza
What does Constant Gain do exactly?


Adds a user-specified (positive or negative and in increments of 1,5 dB) gain to the selected files.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.