Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: dvd backups and loss of sound quality
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Hydrogenaudio Forum > Scientific Discussion
abrahammer
hi, i have a question that's been bugging me for a while. I have many DVD backups of lossless music and i wonder now if my dvd burner can't do good quality burning (it's a cheap burner) then maybe all of my music has lost sound quality as it has been copied from the hard drive to the dvd or maybe as the dvd's deteriorate with time this could have happened. I always check the integrity of the files with audiotester, but maybe sound quality is lost in a subtle way that is undetectable by file integrity tests. żDo these tests give me 100% certainty that my file stays the same as when it was originally ripped or should i also make md5 checksums? (i'm a bit obsessed with the quality of my backups laugh.gif) Sorry if my english is weird.
Tahnru
QUOTE (abrahammer @ Sep 24 2009, 16:51) *
hi, i have a question that's been bugging me for a while. I have many DVD backups of lossless music and i wonder now if my dvd burner can't do good quality burning (it's a cheap burner) then maybe all of my music has lost sound quality as it has been copied from the hard drive to the dvd or maybe as the dvd's deteriorate with time this could have happened. I always check the integrity of the files with audiotester, but maybe sound quality is lost in a subtle way that is undetectable by file integrity tests. żDo these tests give me 100% certainty that my file stays the same as when it was originally ripped or should i also make md5 checksums? (i'm a bit obsessed with the quality of my backups laugh.gif) Sorry if my english is weird.


What are your backup files in? FLAC?
abrahammer
QUOTE (Tahnru @ Sep 24 2009, 15:57) *
QUOTE (abrahammer @ Sep 24 2009, 16:51) *
hi, i have a question that's been bugging me for a while. I have many DVD backups of lossless music and i wonder now if my dvd burner can't do good quality burning (it's a cheap burner) then maybe all of my music has lost sound quality as it has been copied from the hard drive to the dvd or maybe as the dvd's deteriorate with time this could have happened. I always check the integrity of the files with audiotester, but maybe sound quality is lost in a subtle way that is undetectable by file integrity tests. żDo these tests give me 100% certainty that my file stays the same as when it was originally ripped or should i also make md5 checksums? (i'm a bit obsessed with the quality of my backups laugh.gif) Sorry if my english is weird.


What are your backup files in? FLAC?


mostly FLAC but i have some APE's and WAVPACK's. Does this matter?
stranhoROX
If your file can be read from the DVD with no errors, then there's no quality issue. Stop worrying yourself.
Tahnru
QUOTE (abrahammer @ Sep 24 2009, 17:09) *
QUOTE (Tahnru @ Sep 24 2009, 15:57) *
QUOTE (abrahammer @ Sep 24 2009, 16:51) *
hi, i have a question that's been bugging me for a while. I have many DVD backups of lossless music and i wonder now if my dvd burner can't do good quality burning (it's a cheap burner) then maybe all of my music has lost sound quality as it has been copied from the hard drive to the dvd or maybe as the dvd's deteriorate with time this could have happened. I always check the integrity of the files with audiotester, but maybe sound quality is lost in a subtle way that is undetectable by file integrity tests. żDo these tests give me 100% certainty that my file stays the same as when it was originally ripped or should i also make md5 checksums? (i'm a bit obsessed with the quality of my backups laugh.gif) Sorry if my english is weird.


What are your backup files in? FLAC?


mostly FLAC but i have some APE's and WAVPACK's. Does this matter?


Not particularly. I asked out of curiosity. One common approach for the ultra-paranoid is to use the space savings of lossless compression to include PAR files on the backup DVD's. You might like this solution?
abrahammer
yeah, sounds good, okay thanks for answering smile.gif
southisup
DVDisaster might reassure you with future backups.
Eli
I would recommend this over either PAR2 or dvdisaster:

http://www.ice-graphics.com/ICEECC/IndexE.html
pdq
QUOTE (Eli @ Sep 25 2009, 08:02) *
I would recommend this over either PAR2 or dvdisaster:

http://www.ice-graphics.com/ICEECC/IndexE.html

Will that work on discs with unreadable sectors, not just files that contain corrupted data?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.