Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: EAC and offset
Hydrogenaudio Forums > Hydrogenaudio Forum > General Audio
raffal
Should i use the offset option in drive and compresion options in EAC ?

What is this anyway ?

Sorry 4 my english wink.gif
rjamorim
Here's what offset correction is supposed to do. (Taken from EAC's page):

QUOTE

'Sample Offset' is another new feature of EAC, it will help to always get the same WAVs compared to a different reader and to prevent generation losses. Nearly all drives can not position the head correctly. That means if the program tells the drive to read block 10000 it will probably read data somewhere in block 9998 instead. But this is not visible to the reading program, it won't know if it is really the data it wanted. Usually the head will be set always to a fixed offset before or after the correct read position.


I use this feature just to be sure.
There is a table with lots of drive models and respective offsets here:
http://www.ping.be/satcp/eacoffsets01.htm

Regards;

Roberto.
Fede
Thanks Roberto,

can you explain me what is exactly the difference between the drive OFFSET and the compression OFFSET? I've read the EAC readme but i can exactly understand what is it.

Fede
Daffy
Offset correction is highly debatable. In fact, the creator of EAC, Andre Wiethoff doesn't even use it. See his quote in this thread on the EAC forum:

http://www.digital-inn.de/showthread.php?threadid=8298

Also, follow PIO2001's link in this thread for links to more discussion on the subject matter.

Daffy
Fede
Thanks Daffy,

I'm reading the posts you've suggested me, but i've find only explanations about the drive OFFSET and not about the compression. Sorry, it's my fault because i've not clearly write that i know what is the drive OFFSET, but the problem is the compression OFFSET. Wich encoder (all?) creates an OFFSET on my mp3 and how i can know how long is it?

thanks,

Fede
Daffy
I don't use compression offset either. The best explanation I can find comes directly from the original EAC Turtorial at The Coaster Factory webage:

QUOTE
Use Offset Correction for encoding and decoding: (Default: Disabled, Recommended: Disabled) Some compressors do not compress the audio data as is, but they introduce an offset error so that at the beginning is silence and at the end often these number of samples (or more) are missing. This could be bad for compressed live recordings, as they can't be reproduced without gap anymore. By specifying this flag on compression the file will be stuffed and on decompression, by using the offset, the original file could be reconstructed (in most cases).

I do not recommend to use this option. The offset detection uses the default installed codec to determine the offset of the selected compressor, and this codec is not per definition the decoder you use to decode the files! For example, if you use the LAME encoder and have the Fraunhofer codec installed for playing MP3 files, EAC will detect and use the offset between those two. However when you use LAME to decode your files instead of Fraunhofer you are using the wrong offset! And if you distribute your compressed files, how can you know which decoder the recipients will use to decode your files. Some encoders (LAME for example) even already correct their own offset (that is if you use LAME for both encoding and decoding). Thus leave this option disabled unless you know what you are doing and are sure that you have the correct offset correction!


For more information on how to set up EAC, go here:

http://www.ping.be/satcp/tutorials.htm

Daffy
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.